Live data from Hacker News

Deter House Sparrows from your hanging feeder with a Magic Halo (2017)

magichalo.org

31–33 of 33 posts

Re: Deter House Sparrows from your hanging feeder with a Magic Halo (2017)

#31

This surprised me, House Sparrows here in the UK seem to get along with other small birds just fine, I never see any aggression at feeders or in the hedgerows.

Might have something to do with house sparrows evolving there and it being their native range, so other animals have had time to learn how to deal with them.

Re: Deter House Sparrows from your hanging feeder with a Magic Halo (2017)

#32
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, considering adaptation would take years and depending on widespread adoption, this seems a very useful tool to employ for some time. Very far from “stupid things humans do”.

Arbitrarily prefer on bird over another, and believe that you can do something about it with passive-aggressive architecture. That is neither dog stupidity, zebra stupidity nor jellyfish stupidity. That is human stupidity in action.

It isn't arbitrary - it is preferring native species to invasive species. Whether you agree with the logic or not - it isn't arbitrary.

Re: Deter House Sparrows from your hanging feeder with a Magic Halo (2017)

#33
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

House Sparrows are invasive in the United States and they are very aggressive. They destroy the nests of native birds to eliminate competition.

That is peculiar. Because in the Netherlands the native house sparrow population has declined significantly since the '90s.

Same is happening with Starlings. They are in decline in Europe but they thrive the North America
Post reply on HN