Live data from Hacker News

Elan School

elan.school

31–40 of 59 posts

Re: Elan School

#31
I went to a similar programme as a kid and then was horrified to see the same techniques at a rehab I attended as an adult. There have been some improvements, especially in the previously lawless states as Utah, but I'm certain there are still countless schools abusing students in the same or similar methods.

A lot of these treatment methodologies are descended from what was done at Synanon. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=43uD12ooM7U is a good primer video on this.)

Re: Elan School

#32
post #2

I was completely unaware of the existence of Elan School and I couldn't find much on the site that talks about what's going on unless you actually read the comic. Unfortunately it's the middle of the work day so I don't have time to read the comic right now but I wanted to know what it was about to know if I should come back to it. If you're in a similar boat: Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"thera…

> Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"therapeutic" boarding school in Maine that engaged in some extremely controversial practices: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Élan_School Not that I'm doubting any intentions here, but I think dressing this up as "extremely controversial" might be under-selling or burying the lede a bit. Had the practices (the ring, isolation, management structure) that occurred at…

While they are surely morally bankrupt and abhorrent, they aren't "war crimes of the highest order". Let's not dilute and devalue what war crimes are for internet punchiness when they are happening even today.

War crimes are when you break the rules of war. America mistreating its own population does not amount to war crimes.

Re: Elan School

#33
post #2

I was completely unaware of the existence of Elan School and I couldn't find much on the site that talks about what's going on unless you actually read the comic. Unfortunately it's the middle of the work day so I don't have time to read the comic right now but I wanted to know what it was about to know if I should come back to it. If you're in a similar boat: Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"thera…

> Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"therapeutic" boarding school in Maine that engaged in some extremely controversial practices: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Élan_School Not that I'm doubting any intentions here, but I think dressing this up as "extremely controversial" might be under-selling or burying the lede a bit. Had the practices (the ring, isolation, management structure) that occurred at…

Yeah I wasn't trying to downplay how horrible what they did was, more just trying to use neutral/editorial language :shrug:

Re: Elan School

#34
The series is ongoing - sign up using your email and get the next episode.

One interesting side effect is that the author’s art is evolving as they write the episodes.

The scariest part for me is to think where else are things worse than that? I have led an extremely sheltered life by comparison.

Re: Elan School

#35
post #2

I was completely unaware of the existence of Elan School and I couldn't find much on the site that talks about what's going on unless you actually read the comic. Unfortunately it's the middle of the work day so I don't have time to read the comic right now but I wanted to know what it was about to know if I should come back to it. If you're in a similar boat: Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"thera…

> Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"therapeutic" boarding school in Maine that engaged in some extremely controversial practices: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Élan_School Not that I'm doubting any intentions here, but I think dressing this up as "extremely controversial" might be under-selling or burying the lede a bit. Had the practices (the ring, isolation, management structure) that occurred at…

Here is where I first heard of the Elan School: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7eM7pb5M5DU

Re: Elan School

#36

Warning : The read is really-long (multiple-hour), and potentially PTSD trigger inducing. Interesting but disturbing. Happy that such hell-hole is now closed. There is also a documentary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children_of_Darkness (available on Netflix) about the school.

> PTSD trigger inducing.

I will second this -- I found it the other night and made it 8 pages in before it was too much to keep going

Re: Elan School

#37
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quoted post unavailable.

In a lot of U.S. states now, the age is as high as 12. The U.S. has gone absolutely insane in the name of protecting children. And, if you dare question the wisdom of any of these policies, you're typically met with something like, "I guess you just want children to DIE". As an aside, there's also this creepy trend in the U.S. to refer to 15 and 16 year-olds as "children". If someone had referred to me as a child at…

Can you explain as to why you can't send children to play in a park? I don't understand, like far away or even near their home?

Re: Elan School

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Elan School was apparently a behavior modification/"therapeutic" boarding school in Maine that engaged in some extremely controversial practices: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Élan_School Not that I'm doubting any intentions here, but I think dressing this up as "extremely controversial" might be under-selling or burying the lede a bit. Had the practices (the ring, isolation, management structure) that occurred at…

While they are surely morally bankrupt and abhorrent, they aren't "war crimes of the highest order". Let's not dilute and devalue what war crimes are for internet punchiness when they are happening even today. War crimes are when you break the rules of war. America mistreating its own population does not amount to war crimes.

These would be categorized as crimes against humanity.

Re: Elan School

#40

This is horrifying. Can we be sure something like this isn't still happening? Are there people trying to help stop this kind of thing? I don't even know where to start.

Imagine the horrors of the Uighur reeducation camps. 10000x the scale but with rape and physical torture.

I made it only 20 slides into this comic. I didn’t have it this bad but it triggered memories of the high-control group (a term much better and more descriptive than “cult”) I used to be part of.

There’s definitely some tried and true methods of mentally destroying and controlling human beings.

Post reply on HN