Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 48 posts

Re: Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

#31

I did. Best thing I ever did. Was hired back with 25% more pay. After switching I realized the job I had was a very rare “not a web app with a database” and I wanted back to my old gig with actual interesting problems.

Just out of curiosity, what made you decide to leave in the first place?

Re: Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

#32
In 8 years I saw it once. A mobile app lead dev couldn't increase his salary at his old company, and they seemed a bit stuck on allowing him to do certain things. He joined my workplace at the time and was responsible for an app that moved nowhere. After 8 months he'd refactored the entire app, couldn't come up with more to do, and was slightly frustrated about the pace and anarchy, and he negotiated a deal with his old employer, who had realised how valuable he was. Nobody was upset, it was all cool.

I often considered joining an old employer. I never did because the ways in which they were stuck are still true, and I think "changing the system from within" can be a lost cause. But if I were truly stuck, I'd know who to call.

Re: Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

#33
Not in tech, but I've seen it in my current company across all departments and in middle management to upper management.

It seems to me it happens more when there's truly great people and interesting projects in general at the core of the company, but the dealbreaker is "temporary" stuff like salary, a stinker of a project, refusal to promote, etc.

Re: Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

#37
My employer would essentially blacklist you if you left so you could never come back. They're getting desperate for people and are now making some exceptions. It's not very common though. Plus, most people don't want to come back (pay tends to be lower).

Re: Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

#39
post #37

My employer would essentially blacklist you if you left so you could never come back. They're getting desperate for people and are now making some exceptions. It's not very common though. Plus, most people don't want to come back (pay tends to be lower).

I may be an exception to the rule, but I went back three times to the same company in the last ten years for large pay increases and promotions each time (30% increase over previous salary the first go-'round, 50% increase over second turn's salary the second go-'round). I ended up leaving again both times after 1.5-2 years, largely for the same reasons I left the first time, i.e., fatigue and widespread low company morale. Totally worth it though as ultimately it helped increase my negotiating power for other opportunities I pursued in between those stints.

It's been about a year and a half since I last left them - I suspect one of their veeps will be reaching out sometime in the next few months just to "see how (I'm) doing"...I don't think I'd go back this time if they do reach out unless they throw obscenely obscene amounts of money my way.

Re: Ask HN: How common is it for people to come back to a previous employer?

#40
I would say it is extremely common if: The company sells something where development needs a _lot_ of domain knowledge AND the employee is a subject matter expert in said niche domain knowledge.

In this situation a lot of the top people will just keep doing stints anywhere between 2 and 7 years bouncing between major competitors in the field.

Pharma, Automotive, Semiconductor fabrication, are good examples of this.

Arguably in some countries where the law allows it non-compete terms may limit this.

Post reply on HN