Live data from Hacker News

Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

edge.app

31–40 of 104 posts

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#31

Not sure what Edge is but clearly it’s a deeply unserious organization that uses memes to respond to serious (and absolutely worthy of debate) requests.

The Canadian government is a deeply unserious organization that abuses emergency powers to lock people out of the financial system.

> and absolutely worthy of debate

No, it's worthy of ridicule, which is the right move here.

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#32
post #17

What a childish response and a great way to invite future regulation. I’m not an Edge customer but if I was I wouldn’t be anymore. Why would I entrust my money with a company that ignores the law and responds in memes?

Is it against the law for a US company to say "No" to a "request" by the Canadian government? Does edge even have a presence in Canada or need to follow Canadian laws(if the request is actually a demand)?

To me, it's not even clear from that article that Edge received a request from the Canadian government. This reads more as good PR / linkbait to get eyeballs.

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#34

When this protest started, people were complaining that the government was approaching the protest with relative tolerance compared to things like pipeline protests. Well, now protestors are being arrested and their accounts being frozen. They're no longer being treated nicely compared to environmental protestors. While I don't agree with their stance, I do think that "we should not have a vaccine mandate" is a valid…

> now protestors are being arrested

Environmental protesters are FREQUENTLY arrested, so if you’re upset about these arrests at least have the decency to also be upset about these ones last year:

https://thenarwhal.ca/rcmp-arrests-wetsuweten-media-photos/

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#36

What a childish response and a great way to invite future regulation. I’m not an Edge customer but if I was I wouldn’t be anymore. Why would I entrust my money with a company that ignores the law and responds in memes?

They are not ignoring the law: “And most importantly, we can’t even if we wanted to.” Sounds like they are a non-custodial wallet or similar. While they may truly believe the law is amoral and are in part happy to make that statement, this is primarily a marketing stunt for the pro-privacy and unseizable aspects of self-custodied crypto wallets.

They should have opened with the facts. Then put the meme. Plus, that wasn't even the best "no" meme to choose.

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#37

Not sure what Edge is but clearly it’s a deeply unserious organization that uses memes to respond to serious (and absolutely worthy of debate) requests.

small-time crypto- exchange getting some free press for itself

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#39
post #21

What a childish response and a great way to invite future regulation. I’m not an Edge customer but if I was I wouldn’t be anymore. Why would I entrust my money with a company that ignores the law and responds in memes?

Presumably because "government not able to seize my money" >>>>> "government able to seize money of my opponents". (I am not an Edge customer either)

It's amazing how many people don't understand "government can take money from people I don't like" == "government can take money from me"

Re: Official Response: Request to Freeze Canadian Edge Users’ Accounts

#40
post #10

Oof. Not a good look for edge. I'll be the first to admit I think this protest is about a bunch of idiots with a victim complex. They should just get the vaccine like 90% of the rest of their profession have done. It's safe and is what anyone should do to help their fellow humans. The Emergencies Act is law. If Edge wants to do business in Canada they have to follow it. I don't see this ending well for them. Maybe I'…

As a mid-30s sw engineer, I’d say it’s a good look. I hate professional facades and meme’ing is how people communicate now. I’d also say the first part of your your last statement is probably correct, in that you might be an old curmudgeon ;)

I’m sure you’ll begin to appreciate professionalism when your employer starts trying to pay you in memes
Post reply on HN