Live data from Hacker News

The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

newyorker.com

31–40 of 83 posts

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#31

Tarkovsky was an Orthodox Christian, but his ideas about the irreducibility of experience parallel Zen: "Everybody asks me what things mean in my films. This is terrible! An artist doesn't have to answer for his meanings. I don't think so deeply about my work - I don't know what my symbols may represent. What matters to me is that they arouse feelings, any feelings you like, based on whatever your inner response migh…

That's not really Zen though. Zen is expanding your awareness of the present moment to experience it without interpretation, including emotional interpretation, to experience it as it is. Zen is freedom from the constant need to assign meaning and experience feelings about where you are right now. Zen is the calm eye of the storm without attachments to thoughts or emotions, especially those that we use to identify who we are. Zen is a hot cup of tea and the sounds of birds singing.

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#32
post #6

There are some movies you think about for years.. The Sacrifice and Stalker were like that, for me. Tarkovsky's advice to young people is also something I think will ring true with the Hacker News crowd https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Vvdtaaprzw

These English subtitles are masterpiece indeed.

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#33
>A dark aspect of Tarkovsky’s critique of industrial modernity manifests itself: the reversion to a pre-modern order brings with it a reinforcement of male dominance.

Yeah, it wouldn't be the New Yorker without at least a touch of cliché 2022 preoccupations and Zeitgeist, no matter how tacked on and forced it is...

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#34

Oh I like Tarkovsky. Nothing puts me right to sleep like his films do. Set up a 1h off-timer and sweet dreams!

That's so funny. For years I couldn't watch Stalker because I would sleep.

The Pandemic gave me the time to finally watch it during the day.

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#36

I don't think his work travels particularly well in the West. It is steeped in symbolism, deep metaphysics and calm, meditative, photography. All attributes that have been essentially banned from the fast food production/consumption chain that has conditioned audiences. Its a bit like pop music. If all you've ever heard is (basic) western harmony and suddenly get exposed to some weird oriental stuff it does not even…

Wow that's a big statement, about the west. I just watched Nine Days (US, https://ninedaysfilm.com) which was rich with Tarkovskian references. I could name hundreds of western films that are deeply moving and affecting beyond their words. Where to start.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Art_film#Timeline_of_notable_f...

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#37
If you want to truly watch and dive into a tarkovsky (and auteur cinéma in general) film I highly advise you to watch them in your local cinémathèque/cineteca. I've watched the films years ago on a laptop but when I recently saw some during the retrospective at the kinemathek in Berlin it was an incomparable experience.

Edit: plus you'll see the films with their lovely original laser subtitles.

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#38

Tarkovsky was an Orthodox Christian, but his ideas about the irreducibility of experience parallel Zen: "Everybody asks me what things mean in my films. This is terrible! An artist doesn't have to answer for his meanings. I don't think so deeply about my work - I don't know what my symbols may represent. What matters to me is that they arouse feelings, any feelings you like, based on whatever your inner response migh…

I really agree with this. I find it so superficial when people attempt to find a singular “meaning” to a film. A film is not about one thing. It’s an experience. Reducing it down to one idea removes the complexity and nuance of that experience.

Re: The Drenching Richness of Andrei Tarkovsky

#40
> Watching it [The Mirror] is like attending a séance of the twentieth-century Russian soul.

Very well put. I would agree. The Mirror is my favorite Tarkovsky film. I wouldn't even call it a film, it's more more like a poem in movie form.

Post reply on HN