Live data from Hacker News

Imgur Acquired by Medialab

imgur.com

31–40 of 302 posts

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#31
post #6

Wasn't this the company that ostensibly began on reddit? Their founder used to post many promises about "not selling out" and the rest.

They began on Reddit because Reddit was incapable of handling image uploads.

> They began on Reddit because Reddit was incapable of handling image uploads.

I'd argue they largely still are incapable of handling image uploads. Their gallery system sucks and the redesign just makes it harder to even see what was posted.

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#32
I have never seen a service decline so quickly from "simple and actually pretty useful" to "bloated, slow mess" as Imgur. I don't see that trend reversing for them. I suspect much of the slowness is because I live in the ass end of the world (NZ), but that's a problem that can be solved with money.... money they likely don't want to spend.

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#33
post #11

Wasn't this the company that ostensibly began on reddit? Their founder used to post many promises about "not selling out" and the rest.

My favorite part is that they added 'social' stuff to imgur uploads, so your images (probably) have a separate set of terrible comments you're not even aware of.

To be fair, the Imgur comments are actually pretty funny

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#34
post #8

Interesting, I hadn't heard of MediaLab until just a few days ago when I listened to a Darknet Diaries episode[1] about Kik and some "content problems" that MediaLab are leaving unresolved. [1] https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/93/

That exactly the first thought that came to my mind as well. RIP Imgur? It doesn't seem like medialab is anything more than the 'internet brand' version of a patent troll.

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#35
post #13
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They began on Reddit because Reddit was incapable of handling image uploads.

IIRC at the time imgur launched, all of the other free image sharing websites were pretty bad. Reddit itself didn't start allowing uploads until long after imgur.

Here's a data analysis I made years ago on how Reddit native image uploads overtook Imgur uploads: https://minimaxir.com/2017/06/imgur-decline/

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#36

Medialab's other things include like, Genius (ok, fair enough, sustains itself / useful/ well-used I'm assuming)....and Kik? The teen messaging app from like 2010 that no one uses anymore? hm Had to look a bit harder to even find their website ( https://www.medialab.la/ ) - 'a holding company of consumer internet brands' heh, sheesh, yeah that's not sketchy.

oh the Genius acquisition was also (announced) today?! wow someone just went shopping eh?

Edit: Sorry missed that was news from the 16th:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28550527

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#37

Wasn't this the company that ostensibly began on reddit? Their founder used to post many promises about "not selling out" and the rest.

everyone sells out eventually. nothing wrong with it. either that or they run it into the ground or die. people move on that's just life. congrats to the imgur team and good luck for their next adventures.

You don't need to sell out if you can create a service or product that people are willing to pay money for - even indirectly. Granted, this is certainly a difficult feat to pull on a free image hosting site.

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Correct. ImageShack was the most widely used host on reddit and had recently disabled hotlinking (after nearly a year of ad bloat on their main site) so user MrGrim on reddit created Imgur and announced it on Reddit 12 years ago: https://old.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/7zlyd/my_gift_t... He did an AMA 3 years later: https://old.reddit.com//r/IAmA/comments/y81ju/i_created_imgu...

Holy crap, I have not thought about imageshack for a decade. It was hot garbage: slow, ad ridden and if I recall correctly they would disable your hotlinked images if they used too much bandwidth. Imgur was something of a godsend at the time. Now it's commodity unfortunately.

The disabled hotlink images are the only reason I know imageshack exists. How’s that for marketing?

Re: Imgur Acquired by Medialab

#39

This is a tough one to make sense of - are they just getting killed by reddit on one side and tiktok on the other and cashing out? Anyone have any insight? (also anyone know the purchase price? just for fun)

it use to be my fav time waster app rather than the selfies on IG or silly politics on FB. but yea rarely use it now so I guess engagement is dropping

There is definitely a dedicated subculture there with their own rules (e.g. selfies being mercilessly down voted in usersub). Also the demographic was relatable for me as it skewed more towards older millennials.
Post reply on HN