Live data from Hacker News

Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

blog.mozilla.org

31–40 of 109 posts

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're gonna have to support the statement that ESNI is fundamentally flawed a bit better for that argument to work.

From Mozilla link above: Since publication of the ESNI draft specification at the IETF, analysis has shown that encrypting only the SNI extension provides incomplete protection. As just one example: during session resumption, the Pre-Shared Key extension could, legally, contain a cleartext copy of exactly the same server name that is encrypted by ESNI. The ESNI approach would require an encrypted variant of every ext…

So it should still make attacks harder even if possible so it's a win isn't it?

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#32

Does that mean that the quest of finding a working direct link to the image/video will soon become impossible?

Exactly - why do I as a user want this? I already need an extension to fake the Referer...

Which extension?

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#34
post #24

Any idea when they'll fix Firefox so you can make streaming calls without turning your MBP into a toaster? 40x the battery usage vs. Safari when on a streaming call. It's so painful. Heh, literally. The machine gets too hot to hold comfortably. It's still my primary browser, but optimization is needed. Sucks to have to change browsers just to make calls. We live on streaming calls now. This has been an issue since at…

what is a streaming call? webrtc applications like google meet?

Google Meet, Zoom, etc.

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#35

Any idea when they'll fix Firefox so you can make streaming calls without turning your MBP into a toaster? 40x the battery usage vs. Safari when on a streaming call. It's so painful. Heh, literally. The machine gets too hot to hold comfortably. It's still my primary browser, but optimization is needed. Sucks to have to change browsers just to make calls. We live on streaming calls now. This has been an issue since at…

That sounds like a reproducible bug report, with an easy test case (“run this script and measure laptop battery life, in Firefox and Safari”). If you haven’t already provided that in a bug report to the software developers, you should do so. Shopping your concern to an unrelated thread about security headers isn’t likely to get far on HN, certainly nowhere near as much as a testable bug would.

Eh, I'm willing to take a few downvotes if it means raising awareness. I tag pretty much every Firefox post with some sort of report on battery life. I've added bug reports... doesn't ever seem to get taken seriously. Like I said I'm OK with taking a few downvotes on the off chance someone on the Firefox team may actually see this and be able to prioritize work to address the issue.

Firefox is my primary browser, but this issue in the age of Covid makes it fundamentally flawed. Heard all the responses, "Stop trying to use Firefox on a Mac, it's Apple's fault..." and not unsympathetic, just feels more can be done.

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#36

Does that mean that the quest of finding a working direct link to the image/video will soon become impossible?

Exactly - why do I as a user want this? I already need an extension to fake the Referer...

The article explains why you as a user want this.

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#37

Any idea when they'll fix Firefox so you can make streaming calls without turning your MBP into a toaster? 40x the battery usage vs. Safari when on a streaming call. It's so painful. Heh, literally. The machine gets too hot to hold comfortably. It's still my primary browser, but optimization is needed. Sucks to have to change browsers just to make calls. We live on streaming calls now. This has been an issue since at…

You'll likely need a laptop CPU/GPU/APU, OS, browser, and site that natively support WebRTC and the media codec being used in hardware as much as possible. That's probably going to be AV1 support across the board for the foreseeable future. That's probably a couple years out.

Real time AV codecs generally did not choose the "cheap" aspect of the "good / fast / cheap" triangle.

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#38

Does that mean that the quest of finding a working direct link to the image/video will soon become impossible?

Exactly - why do I as a user want this? I already need an extension to fake the Referer...

Developer tools / Network / find necessary resource / Right click / Copy as cURL

Re: Firefox 90 supports Fetch Metadata Request Headers

#39

Any idea when they'll fix Firefox so you can make streaming calls without turning your MBP into a toaster? 40x the battery usage vs. Safari when on a streaming call. It's so painful. Heh, literally. The machine gets too hot to hold comfortably. It's still my primary browser, but optimization is needed. Sucks to have to change browsers just to make calls. We live on streaming calls now. This has been an issue since at…

You'll likely need a laptop CPU/GPU/APU, OS, browser, and site that natively support WebRTC and the media codec being used in hardware as much as possible. That's probably going to be AV1 support across the board for the foreseeable future. That's probably a couple years out. Real time AV codecs generally did not choose the "cheap" aspect of the "good / fast / cheap" triangle.

I hear this, but also it works fine in Safari... and even less bad in Chrome on a MBP. Not an expert, but that makes me think there's something the Firefox folks can do to improve this issue. If they wanted to.

It's not like 2x, it's like 40x more power used. This makes the MBP super heat. Thing was never cool to start, but I suspect it's getting hot enough to shorten the battery life. It's really hot. Happens on every MBP 16" I've tested it on.

Grab 2-3 friends, fire up Zoom, Google Meets, or stream something on Twitch (or whatever service you want). And you'll hear the fans kick in, and the machine's temp will rapidly rise. Toggle open the power inspector, or just watch as 1-2% of the battery life drains per minute.

Post reply on HN