Live data from Hacker News

Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

venturebeat.com

31–40 of 69 posts

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#34

Everything microsoft attempts is so desperately uncool that the very concept of Microsoft doing social is futile. There is literally no way they could make this work. It's another Ballmer "car crash in slow motion" initiative. /popcorn

Maybe, but it could still provide useful competition in a market which desperately needs some. (No, two players are not enough.)

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#35

Everything microsoft attempts is so desperately uncool that the very concept of Microsoft doing social is futile. There is literally no way they could make this work. It's another Ballmer "car crash in slow motion" initiative. /popcorn

What about Kinect? Microsoft is big and there are a lot of people who like Microsoft or at least some products of it despite you like that or not. E.g. I have not seen Windows programming company without Microsoft evangelist yet. There are even more people who are indifferent to technology (similarly to human rights, wars, environment issues, religion and etc.).

Therefore Microsoft making social is not futile while I'm not sure if they really need that.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#36

Everything microsoft attempts is so desperately uncool that the very concept of Microsoft doing social is futile. There is literally no way they could make this work. It's another Ballmer "car crash in slow motion" initiative. /popcorn

And they're again last to the party... they desperately need a Bill Gates again, or at least someone with vision.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#37
looking at the screenshot, and actually reading the content of the small tiles, this does not look like G+/facebook/twitter, but more like a wikia/knol/stack*/quora.

I mean, there isn't anything in this single screenshot suggesting this as a new "generalistic" social network , so why are so many comments to this submission trying to frame it so?

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#38
post #3

I have trouble believing all these "accidental leakages" are actually accidents. The new trendy marketing gimmick?

very true...its all Mktng gimmick....this strategy offers free publicity. See what happend to iphone4...huge hit after " Being left at a bar Accidently :D "

[deleted]

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#39
post #15
post #3

I have trouble believing all these "accidental leakages" are actually accidents. The new trendy marketing gimmick?

It's their traditional "don't commit your efforts to our competitor - our product is just around the corner".

Invitation only rollouts would appear to follow a similar thought process.
Post reply on HN