Live data from Hacker News

Stripe Tax

stripe.com

31–40 of 383 posts

Re: Stripe Tax

#31
A few questions I think are interesting:

Does Stripe do well in a world where governments provide efficient and easy online payments? Places like Sweden with Swish.

Does Stripe do well in a world where governments provide simplified/near-zero-work tax calculation mechanisms? .

Re: Stripe Tax

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you feel like the value is worth with the fee Stripe is charging?

YES, considering the only best competitor in this space Paddle takes 5%. Taxes is the reason why in the past most EU/UK businesses go to Paddle. Stripe's Tax feature now saves people who were considering Paddle a lot of time now.

That's the reason I use 2Checkout (formerly Avangate). I can issue one invoice a month, in my own currency. That saves a lot of work and aggravation.

Re: Stripe Tax

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

YES, considering the only best competitor in this space Paddle takes 5%. Taxes is the reason why in the past most EU/UK businesses go to Paddle. Stripe's Tax feature now saves people who were considering Paddle a lot of time now.

Do you know if Paddle files taxes for you? And just send you 1099? Or it is similar to Stripe Tax, they just collect and you have to file taxes?

Paddle and FastSpring (I found their support to be more helpful than Paddle's but they charge even higher fees), the two solutions commonly used in that space, act as Merchants of Record. Since you are not selling directly to your users you don't have to file the corresponding taxes, just the ones that correspond to the transactions between Paddle/FastSpring and you. But I'm not an accountant and they may change their operations in the future so don't rely on this comment alone.

Re: Stripe Tax

#34
post #9

Wouldn't most online businesses just need to collect the taxes for the customers that their business operates in? Posting this on the basis that there should be no stupid questions when it comes to tax. For example; an Australian business needs to collect GST for Australian customers only. Americans accessing the Australian service would not be obligated to pay GST and as the Australian business doesn't have a US ent…

That kind of used to be the way it worked, but not for the last several years. Now you are generally expected to know about the tax laws and requirements for the customers region and collect and submit tax accordingly.

Avalara (https://www.avalara.com/us/en/products/sales-and-use-tax/ava...) has been one of the go-to software platforms for this purpose. At least according to my wife, who is a CFO, and generally has to manage this stuff.

Re: Stripe Tax

#36
post #9

Wouldn't most online businesses just need to collect the taxes for the customers that their business operates in? Posting this on the basis that there should be no stupid questions when it comes to tax. For example; an Australian business needs to collect GST for Australian customers only. Americans accessing the Australian service would not be obligated to pay GST and as the Australian business doesn't have a US ent…

That's not how it works within Europe. You need to collect taxes in the country where your customer is located, you need to register with VAT instances in those countries. There are exceptions, for example up to some total revenue you may be allowed to collect local sales tax instead. This is what I've understood, but it probably gets more complicated in real.

> You need to collect taxes in the country where your customer is located, you need to register with VAT instances in those countries

Correct for the 1st part, on the 2nd part there is a VAT MOSS (One Stop Shop) where you report it in one place your sales/VAT for all the EU countries

Re: Stripe Tax

#37

Very happy to see this, it is such a necessary feature. I was recently looking for an option to enable VAT calculation in Stripe and couldn't believe it wasn't there. Now it is, and it looks very well done as Stripe's features usually are. But 0.5% fee per transaction is.. steep.

Thanks for the feedback! Completely understand your reaction to pricing. For a bit of context, we’ve spent the past year listening to users and trying to understand the best way to price. In finalizing our launch pricing, we made sure there are no fixed upfront costs or contracts, nor are there any per transaction fixed fees either. We tried to find a price point that ultimately was not prohibitive for small businesses but also portrayed the value of the product itself. Please do keep the feedback coming, we’re always open to hearing more from users: kmoriarty@stripe.com

Re: Stripe Tax

#38
Note this big gotcha:

Stripe's VIES validation only takes place once and there is no way to retrigger it.

For compliance purposes you have to validate it yourself every quarter or so, on recurring transactions.

Re: Stripe Tax

#40

A few questions I think are interesting: Does Stripe do well in a world where governments provide efficient and easy online payments? Places like Sweden with Swish. Does Stripe do well in a world where governments provide simplified/near-zero-work tax calculation mechanisms? .

Stripe and Swish solve different problems. Swish is mobile phone based direct bank transfers, Stripe is credit/debit card transactions. The big problem with Swish is that it only works if you have a phone with a Swedish SIM card and a Swedish bank account in a supported bank (which admittedly is most of them). With Stripe you can take money from anyone with a Visa or Mastercard
Post reply on HN