Live data from Hacker News

Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

valisure.com

31–40 of 309 posts

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#31

What if skin cancer was actually caused by sun screen? Wouldn't that be ironic, don't ya think?

Well that’s what this is saying, some sunscreens contain unacceptably high levels of carcinogens. It’s not a huge logical leap to go from there to some people getting skin cancer from the sunscreen. That doesn’t mean you aren’t also at risk of getting skin cancer from excess sun exposure.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#32

Gasoline has around 2% Benzene in it, by the way. That’s 20,000ppm vs 6ppm for the worst offenders here. Crazy we let teenagers pump this stuff and then the rest of us just breathe in the fumes.

Yeah but hopefully you don't rub that stuff all over your face and just pump it into your car.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#33
post #13
post #2

So this is bad, obviously, but I want to plug Valisure and consumerlab both. For whatever reason there’s so little testing out there for both generic drugs and vitamins and supplements, and both of these guys really do have our backs. I’m very happy to support both to be doing what I feel like the FDA with more funding should be doing themselves.

I didn't know about Valisure and consumerlab, but have used Labdoor before buying something new. Strongly agree this field of testing/validation is desperately needed.

This seems to be true across markets and regulatory levels.

For example, browser extensions must be analyzed by neutral third parties because the code can not be trusted to be persistently safe with each new publication.

This is similar to different formulations across batches in sunscreen.

I’ve noticed in consumer products like backpacks, the hardware (zipper pulls, etc) can sometimes vary in the same brand and model. The company does not outwardly acknowledge variability, and it is not discussed in product reviews.

Apple made changes to its Secure Enclave Component unusually in fall 2020. [1]

Not every update of every product is going to contain a shocker. But with the rate of releases and rapid adoption of physical and virtual consumer products, we could use less unboxing and more hard analysis of what is shipping and it’s potential for harm.

[1] https://www.macrumors.com/2021/04/12/apple-made-security-cha...

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#34

Most numerous listed: Neutrogena, CVS brand, Banana Boat.

If numerous Dell laptop variants and MacBook Pro were affected by some vulnerability, could still mean that the majority of the vulnerable laptops are MacBook Pros.

The interesting thing to me would be the ratio of shipped products by a brand that are affected. And maybe the total number of affected units.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#35

Gasoline has around 2% Benzene in it, by the way. That’s 20,000ppm vs 6ppm for the worst offenders here. Crazy we let teenagers pump this stuff and then the rest of us just breathe in the fumes.

And some brands/products even have a 70% Std.Dev... seems to be more manufacturing inconsistency and bad quality control.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#36

Gasoline has around 2% Benzene in it, by the way. That’s 20,000ppm vs 6ppm for the worst offenders here. Crazy we let teenagers pump this stuff and then the rest of us just breathe in the fumes.

I can't tell if this is sarcasm. Anyway, I think my exposure to gasoline is higher than to sunscreen.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#37

So going through the list i see Neutrogena a lot. Neutrogena is owned by Johnson and Johnson. Sun Pharmaceuticals owns Banana Boat, Coppertone is owned by a German company called Beiersdorf, CVS Health is the next largest brand to show up and it owns these subsidiaries: CVS Pharmacy, MinuteClinic, CVS Caremark, CVS Specialty, Drogaria Onofre, Longs Drugs, Navarro Discount Pharmacies, Accordant, Coram, Omnicare, Wellp…

I bet if you wait a month, you would get different results. These brands are just brands, they buy product in bulk from manufacturers you've never heard of and stick it in a bottle with a lot of words on it to try to pretend like their product is differentiated.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#39
post #28

Neutrogena is owned by Johnson and Johnson - which just payed out on a case relating to cancer from baby-powders [1]. Combined with Neutrogena being more or less _very high_ in benezine content and J&J having a very deep suite of cancer treatment drugs [2]... This seems like a horrific story of a self-fulfilling product pipeline. I know they're a giant organization and suggesting conspiracy is a bit insane but I can'…

Makes you wonder what else J&J could be doing to other products they manufacture.

Re: Benzene detected in many sunscreen products

#40

Gasoline has around 2% Benzene in it, by the way. That’s 20,000ppm vs 6ppm for the worst offenders here. Crazy we let teenagers pump this stuff and then the rest of us just breathe in the fumes.

I can't tell if this is sarcasm. Anyway, I think my exposure to gasoline is higher than to sunscreen.

Not sarcasm. After driving electric for a while (used are affordable... at least until the last couple months when the price of used cars went through the roof), the smell of gasoline seems especially pungent.
Post reply on HN