Live data from Hacker News

Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

thenextweb.com

31–36 of 36 posts

Re: Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

#31
I think a lot of the growth is/will be in offices where people are working at computers. A group of people with headphones at workstations DJing to each other is very compelling, and turns a part of the environment that can be isolating into something social. Likewise, friends working at different companies can be plugged in to each other in an ambient way while working. That's the coolest part so far.

Beyond that, there seems to be a lot of ad-less Pandora going on: join a genre-focused room and get a stream of stuff you may or may not know without the labor of building a playlist in Grooveshark. As stated elsewhere, this can be annoying though, because people suck at sticking to the stated genre (ie. frantic Drum and Bass in a "chillout" room).

If it really gets traction, it will also become a target for bands to market themselves. I've already seen some DJs spinning their own songs.

Big hurdle: it's ugly. They should fix that, especially since it's basically a "place" to hang out.

Re: Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

#32
post #30

For all the talk about web-based streaming music services as 'discovery', it's odd to note this fixation on "labels". Is there any reason why a service like this couldn't cater to "unsigned" or "non-label" music? This would arguably help "discovery" far more than Arcade Fire fans getting together to spin another AF track.

I used to spend a lot of time on t61 which does exactly what you're talking about. http://www.thesixtyone.com/ I stopped using it when they did the big redesign. I find the new interface nowhere near as good or useful as the old one but I guess if you started using the site today it would probably seem fine to you.

got any screen grabs of the old design? This site looks neat but would like to see where it came from. archive.org seems a bit spotty.

Re: Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

#33
post #11

Mostly, turntable is growing because they are subsidizing free music. The social is gravy, but people love free stuff. At some point they will need to actually cover their costs (note the shutdown of non-us traffic) and it's going to be a lot more difficult. Growth has never been the hard part for music startups. Making money has.

There are hundreds of ways to get free music that haven't had the same explosive growth rate as turntable. I think the article is right in that they've done very well with subtle but surprisingly deep social aspects. I do think they have a huge legal problem looming, especially with regards to letting you play tracks others have uploaded. Google and Amazon are already fighting the 'public performance of copyrighted w…

I agree that it's not the free music aspect that drives Turntable. It's that social recognition for a good song. I was using it with another member of my startup on Friday (before it was banned in Canada) and we created our own room. Literally just the two of us rocking out trading songs. If someone's song sucked, we'd chirp the other person. It makes listening to music fun, which was previously lacking.

Definitely agree on the legal problem here. The whole non-US shutdown doesn't look promising.

Re: Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

#34
post #32
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I used to spend a lot of time on t61 which does exactly what you're talking about. http://www.thesixtyone.com/ I stopped using it when they did the big redesign. I find the new interface nowhere near as good or useful as the old one but I guess if you started using the site today it would probably seem fine to you.

got any screen grabs of the old design? This site looks neat but would like to see where it came from. archive.org seems a bit spotty.

I take that back, they have the old design under the 'old' subdomain. Cool.

Re: Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

#35
post #30

For all the talk about web-based streaming music services as 'discovery', it's odd to note this fixation on "labels". Is there any reason why a service like this couldn't cater to "unsigned" or "non-label" music? This would arguably help "discovery" far more than Arcade Fire fans getting together to spin another AF track.

I used to spend a lot of time on t61 which does exactly what you're talking about. http://www.thesixtyone.com/ I stopped using it when they did the big redesign. I find the new interface nowhere near as good or useful as the old one but I guess if you started using the site today it would probably seem fine to you.

thanks - i'd forgotten about this one

Re: Why Turntable.fm is the most exciting social service of the year

#36
post #34
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

got any screen grabs of the old design? This site looks neat but would like to see where it came from. archive.org seems a bit spotty.

I take that back, they have the old design under the 'old' subdomain. Cool.

Thanks, I had no idea about that. Looks like I can start using the site again. =)
Post reply on HN