Live data from Hacker News

Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

aspe.hhs.gov

31–40 of 114 posts

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#31
This is the survey question, as part of a broader Household Pulse Survey: “Once a vaccine to prevent COVID-19 is available to you, would you…get a vaccine?” No mention of a follow up for rationale.

via https://data.cdc.gov/stories/s/Vaccine-Hesitancy-for-COVID-1...

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#32
post #3

Why does the data change so much on the boundaries of states? I would expect the data to be locally correlated, and there wouldn't be discrepancies between neighboring rural counties that are in different states.

https://aspe.hhs.gov/system/files/pdf/265341/vaccine-hesitan...

"State of residence" was a predictor in their linear model. A person's state (and its government) will probably affect the outcome variable to some extend, so it's not really surprising that it might be retained as a significant term. However, I find it hard to believe it's so important. I wonder if that predictor is simply confounded with some unobserved variable relating to methods of surveying that differed by state.

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#33

This is a pretty interesting map/graph. I also like that they linked to the data in table form. Not really surprised at the areas that are darkest, but still feel worried that lots of areas near 20%. Specifically the levels of non-Hispanic Black hesitancy in the South is really rough. Hopefully over time this improves especially as private enterprises put some pressure on getting vaccinated

> Hopefully over time this improves especially as private enterprises put some pressure on getting vaccinated I really hope I don't lose my job because I don't want to take an experimental, unapproved vaccine for a disease that hospitalizes less than 5% of people across all age groups when I work from home, am a healthy weight, and am under forty. The risk for me is, in fact, comparable to the flu, and the vaccine ha…

Everyone should take the vaccine, but:

> Also are you surprised that Black people in the South don't want this experimental vaccine after the Tuskegee Experiment?

Is a super important and valid point. Historically Black people have had their human rights violated in similar situations. Johnson and Johnson also knowingly targeted Black people with baby powder marketing after they knew it caused cancer. As much as I think it's important to get vaccinated, I wouldn't take the JJ vaccine on principal and personal fear that it's potentially not safe, just based on the company making it (rational or not).

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#34
post #4

This is a pretty interesting map/graph. I also like that they linked to the data in table form. Not really surprised at the areas that are darkest, but still feel worried that lots of areas near 20%. Specifically the levels of non-Hispanic Black hesitancy in the South is really rough. Hopefully over time this improves especially as private enterprises put some pressure on getting vaccinated

The interesting thing that jumped out at me was the blurring of state borders between southern Ohio, West Virginia, and Kentucky.

As someone who lives in Cincinnati, my perception is that the restrictions (reflecting to some extent public opinion) have been mostly middle-of-the-pack in both OH and KY. OH's governor is a moderate Republican who may lose his primary over having restrictions at all, and KY's governor is a Democrat who narrowly won the office in 2019 in a state that's generally pretty conservative. The blurred borders make total sense to me in that context, because not much changes across them.

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#35

You can see the same trends emerging on the maps on the NYT vaccine page: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/covid-19-vaccine... If you scroll to the map with state-level data, you can see it has started to resemble the electoral college map. Having checked it out nearly everyday for months now, that resemblance is only growing stronger as time goes on. At a certain point, there may need to be some designati…

Travel advisories may not be sufficient. At some point we may need the federal government to round up individuals who refused to get vaccines and put them in remedial education camps. These camps could be taxpayer neutral through a mandatory daily forced labor quota for each resident. Due to the potential for virulent "super spreaders" among the populations, residents must be kept in solitary confinement for their own safety. The overarching goal here would be rehabilitation, and we could give it a catchy name like "Ministry of Truth."

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#36
post #29

It's a good day to be a Masshole. According to the spreadsheet, MA is least hesitant by state and together with VT, sweeps the first 14 counties (and the first 19, if you ignore SF).

They got vaccinated so quickly because such a large fraction of them needed to do so as a condition of employment. Healthcare is a massive industry in MA.

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#37
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why are you surprised at San Diego? I know very little about the culture there so I'm curious

There are a lot of military and right-wingers in the San Diego area.

Until recently anti-vacccine was more a left wing thing. (it always has cut across the political spectrum)

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#39
post #29

It's a good day to be a Masshole. According to the spreadsheet, MA is least hesitant by state and together with VT, sweeps the first 14 counties (and the first 19, if you ignore SF).

Meanwhile case numbers on Boston, as determined by sewage surveillance, are holding steady: https://www.mwra.com/biobot/biobotdata.htm

What's going on?

Re: Vaccine Hesitancy for Covid-19: State, County, and Local Estimates

#40
post #4

This is a pretty interesting map/graph. I also like that they linked to the data in table form. Not really surprised at the areas that are darkest, but still feel worried that lots of areas near 20%. Specifically the levels of non-Hispanic Black hesitancy in the South is really rough. Hopefully over time this improves especially as private enterprises put some pressure on getting vaccinated

The interesting thing that jumped out at me was the blurring of state borders between southern Ohio, West Virginia, and Kentucky.

Ohio border is clearly visible but KY/WV blends well. I don't get it though, why would Athens County, OH be almost 4 points higher on the hesitancy scale than Lewis County, KY despite having better vaccination stats?
Post reply on HN