Live data from Hacker News

FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

vice.com

31–40 of 54 posts

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#31
post #2

> By deleting the web shells, FBI personnel will prevent malicious cyber actors from using the web shells to access the servers and install additional malware on them If the FBi is in your computer you have already lost. Your box is as good as dead and you might aswell do a full factory reset or it that's too bothersome, buy a new box. Sometimes buying a whole new box is cheaper than cleaning up malware using special…

...setting up YC company to purchase FBI-"tuned" computers for cheap.

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#33
post #8
post #4

This is probably a net positive for national security... but I still don't like it. I don't want the FBI doing anything to my computer without my permission.

What are you suggesting that by setting this precedent the US Government would use it to illegally and unconstitutionally harm people who are politically unpopular. I do not think this would happen the US government is good the US government is right they protect you and keep you safe from evil terrorists who would try to hurt you. Please do not think about this too much, please go consume your next television show a…

Why come you don't have a tatoo?

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#35
This is a terrible precedent and never should have been rubber-stamped by the court. I hope this attracts enough attention to bubble up to the Supreme Court and the FBI gets slapped. The correct action, if any, would have been to get a court order allowing the offending sites to be disconnected from the Internet.

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#36

Was there a private individual a few years ago who was doing a similar thing? Cleaning up backdoored servers?

> Was there a private individual a few years ago who was doing a similar thing? Cleaning up backdoored servers? Do you mean Max Butler, who was given jail-time after deciding to not be an undercover FBI informant FBI anymore? https://www.securityfocus.com/news/203

What a strange coincidence, he is supposed to get out literally today!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Butler

> Butler is currently incarcerated at FCI Victorville Medium 2 in California, he expected to be released April 14, 2021.

Though it sounds like the sort of things he did involved a lot of carding and other kinda severely shitty behaviour.

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#37
post #5

Sweet, since we now have the precedence that the FBI can invade your machine without permission whenever they want for national security reasons I can't wait the glorious future we have before us. Now the FBI can access your machine and start modifying things because you are expressing displeasure at your public officials which is a sign of "terrorist behavior", oops you're using your blog to say things the governmen…

Is it really that bad and different than what they do in the physical world? If someone breaks into your home and they are still inside when the police show up, they won't just give you a call and tell you someone is inside your home. They will go in there and get the criminal out of your home. The threat actors are actively stealing information and are inside the networks of many companies, some with the expertise t…

Not quite the same. If someone installs a hidden microphone in my house, or a multi keyed lock (where they have a working copy) I really expect the Police to ask me before they come in my house to remove the offending equipment or change my lock for me.

If they come in the house uninvited then all they achieve is make me lose trust in them. I'll just start wondering how long until they abuse this and do it whenever it suits them, not me, if they're not doing it already.

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#38
post #2

> By deleting the web shells, FBI personnel will prevent malicious cyber actors from using the web shells to access the servers and install additional malware on them If the FBi is in your computer you have already lost. Your box is as good as dead and you might aswell do a full factory reset or it that's too bothersome, buy a new box. Sometimes buying a whole new box is cheaper than cleaning up malware using special…

They're using the vulnerability in question to go in and eliminate that vulnerability, locking themselves out. It's like a cop seeing a wide open front door, and going into the threshold in order to reach the door handle so he can pull it closed. Did he go into the house? Yes. Because it was open, and only in order to close it.

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#39
post #2

> By deleting the web shells, FBI personnel will prevent malicious cyber actors from using the web shells to access the servers and install additional malware on them If the FBi is in your computer you have already lost. Your box is as good as dead and you might aswell do a full factory reset or it that's too bothersome, buy a new box. Sometimes buying a whole new box is cheaper than cleaning up malware using special…

They're using the vulnerability in question to go in and eliminate that vulnerability, locking themselves out. It's like a cop seeing a wide open front door, and going into the threshold in order to reach the door handle so he can pull it closed. Did he go into the house? Yes. Because it was open, and only in order to close it.

Except you have no idea what else they're doing in there before they so nicely "close the door".

Besides, your metaphor doesn't work since cops aren't allowed to just enter a premise due to it being unlocked or open. That doesn't fall under any of the reasons to enter a premise without warrant. Leaving a door unlocked or open is not a crime that gives them free pass.

I really have a hard time understanding people's logic on here sometimes. Apparently the entire US government is systemically racist and evil but these same people want to give more power to this government? Which is it?

Re: FBI Accesses Computers Around Country to Delete Microsoft Exchange Hacks

#40

Was there a private individual a few years ago who was doing a similar thing? Cleaning up backdoored servers?

> Was there a private individual a few years ago who was doing a similar thing? Cleaning up backdoored servers? Do you mean Max Butler, who was given jail-time after deciding to not be an undercover FBI informant FBI anymore? https://www.securityfocus.com/news/203

After hacking into people's computers and installing backdoors for himself.
Post reply on HN