Live data from Hacker News

Based Cooking

based.cooking

31–40 of 485 posts

Re: Based Cooking

#31

This is absurd. Many of these recipes don’t even have quantities on them. Needs some kind of QA process at least ....

You could submit a pull request

I’ll stick to reading the many other decent recipe sites, thanks. Kitchn has probably worked best for me so far.

Re: Based Cooking

#32
post #18

I like the idea of a simple recipe site generally, but I also like reading the user feedback on recipe sites. Is a recipe any good? Are there improvements? There is no way to tell on this site.

IMO it's not worth the hassle to add user feedback, because A) it takes a lot of work from the website admin B) it's usually extremely low (maybe negative) value.

For a lot of sites I might agree, but I think individual user experiences and variations provide a lot of value on a cooking site

Re: Based Cooking

#34

In the last few years I’ve learnt that there really is nothing better than a good cook book. Vibrant colors, techniques, stories - these can all really add to your experience if their presence is not solely for the purpose of including additional ads. I’ve also found that the recipe alone is truly not enough - the techniques and background are incredibly important !

> the techniques and background are incredibly important

As someone who admittedly loathes _and_ is bad at cooking - it sounds like you are describing a combination recipe book _and_ cooking-instruction/cooking-history book. I wonder if people are frustrated because the two are getting conflated - they _just_ want the recipe, but they are being given both recipes and background?

Re: Based Cooking

#35
post #18

I like the idea of a simple recipe site generally, but I also like reading the user feedback on recipe sites. Is a recipe any good? Are there improvements? There is no way to tell on this site.

IMO it's not worth the hassle to add user feedback, because A) it takes a lot of work from the website admin B) it's usually extremely low (maybe negative) value.

A friend of mine who frequents recipe sites pointed out to me once how often the comments are some variation of "I made this except I didn't have any X, Y, or Z so I used M, N, and O", which is great for them but it doesn't really tell you if the recipe, as written, is any good.

Re: Based Cooking

#36
post #13

Maybe I'm in a minority, because everyone always hoots and hollers about how they hate modern recipe web sites -- and I get it, 6 pages of memories of trips to grandma or whatever is ridiculous -- but I can't see myself ever using a plain-text recipe with no clue as to who the author is and no reason to suspect that they know what they're talking about. At that point I would probably go to SimplyRecipes, where at lea…

Unless it's something I never tried to make before and isn't like anything I have tried before, I just want an ingredient list and the directions with a color pic of the final dish to entice me.

When deciding between competing recipes I want the ingredient list and a pic of the final product to decide.

I don't want to have to browse and search through the clutter of irrelevant things. I like Punchfork[1] for this. Easy to search, it presents the ingredient list and a pic then you can click through to the site for the instructions --unfortunately the actual sites are usually cluttered with few exceptions.

[1] https://www.punchfork.com/

Re: Based Cooking

#39

In the last few years I’ve learnt that there really is nothing better than a good cook book. Vibrant colors, techniques, stories - these can all really add to your experience if their presence is not solely for the purpose of including additional ads. I’ve also found that the recipe alone is truly not enough - the techniques and background are incredibly important !

Couldn't agree more. A good cookbook is well laid out and organized in a logical manner, rather than organized to optimize search rankings.

And while I'm grateful for youtube, blogs, reddit, etc for reducing the barriers for folks to share information about topics like cooking and home improvement, they've also taught me to appreciate a good editor.

Re: Based Cooking

#40

> Only Based cooking. Can someone shed light on what "based cooking" is? It's rather tricky to Google for and am unable to figure out what the site's author means by that.

"Based" is a specific online subculture slang for something wholly positive, the opposite of "cringe".
Post reply on HN