Live data from Hacker News

Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

github.com

31–40 of 342 posts

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#31
post #19

Time for a p2p app store that works on all devices.

Right so when you have some childporn showing up, illegal material what are you going to do?

Report it to the FBI so the developers of the app get sent to prison, where they belong.

Are you in the habit of reporting serious crimes to the nearest advertising agency?

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#32

I guess the Scunthorpe problem is still a thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem

I'm just agog that people are still doing dumb pattern matching for profanity filters. I just assumed that YEARS AGO people realized how dumb it is, but apparently: No.

I once had a bug that I traced back to a rule (can’t remember in which part of the stack - though I think it was client controlled IIS) that was striping the “select” from the word “selected” in query string params in an attempt to thwart sql injection. From memory it was naive enough that “sselectelect” was converted nicely in the process.

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#33
post #19

Time for a p2p app store that works on all devices.

Right so when you have some childporn showing up, illegal material what are you going to do?

Investigate the people that created or are the primary distributors of the childporn because they are trackable on clearnet, and let everyone else make their own choice of not installing or stop being able to access when the servers disappear?

Can you explain why thats not the first thing that came to mind? Why are our realities so different?

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#34

I guess the Scunthorpe problem is still a thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem

I'm just agog that people are still doing dumb pattern matching for profanity filters. I just assumed that YEARS AGO people realized how dumb it is, but apparently: No.

FWIW, general profanity detection is a highly nontrivial problem. It’s true that such subword profanity filters aren’t that great, but slightly more sophisticated ones (eg whole word matching or n-grams) tend to have relatively good precision. You could train a fancy neural network, but the overall return on precision and recall tends to be not that great (compared to the exponential change in speed and cost). The problem almost always crops up in out-of-distribution sentences (such as “bone” at a paleontology conference).

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#35
post #5

I guess the Scunthorpe problem is still a thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem

Reminiscent to me of Call of Duty Warzone; it has loadouts which you can give custom names (that only you see!) which are protected with a profanity filter. Comically, some of the literal names of the guns are banned as being profane, like "MP5".

My CoD group of friends still occasionally calls the assault rifle "analsault". Stupid, huh? Not as stupid as an earlier version of CoD (Black Ops 1, IIRC) that wouldn't let you name a load out "assault $WHATEVER", 'cuz you know, "ass". But "anal" is so much better so that was allowed.

They fixed it in later versions, but I still have a "penetration" class because I'm immature that way.

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#37
post #14

Time for a p2p app store that works on all devices.

What you're actually saying is: time for government intervention. There's no planet on which Apple or Google will voluntarily give up the revenue stream produced by their respective app stores. *If you're going to downvote me, at least provide some evidence that I'm off base. Google and Apple both refuse to allow other app stores and there's absolutely 0 recourse that doesn't involve the government stepping in. F-dro…

This kind of thing is exactly what anti-trust laws are for.

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#38

Just wanna make sure I got this right. "ASS", automatic instant suspension with 0 human review. "King's Throne: Game of Lust.", with advertised gameplay content such as "I, [the King], shall interrogate this female prisoner privately in my bed chambers", is one of the top advertised games on google play. Got it.

Approved since it doesn't have a naughty word in it. /s

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#39
It is infuriating that Google's default action for these automated takedowns is to remove the app and ask the developer to upload a new build with a new package name, which means not keeping any of the existing users.

It's happened to two of my clients in the past 6 months based on small infractions in the app metadata, but no issue with the app itself.

In both cases the app was taken down with no advance notice, and eventually reinstated after an appeal and several very stressful days of waiting.

Apple seems to be very selective during the approval process, and is often inconsistent so a minor update can get rejected for something that was approved many times before. I guess different people review and interpret the rules differently so maybe this is unavoidable.

Google (from what I can tell) seems to take a very different approach and relies much more on automated enforcement. The process is on average much lower friction for the developer, but getting previously approved app listings removed at any time without warning is not a good experience.

Edit: I forgot to mention that you can't actually edit the metadata while the app is suspended and re-submit it for review. The only two choices are to appeal and edit the description after the app is reinstated, or create a completely new app listing.

Re: Suspended from Google Play for listing supported subtitle formats

#40

Just wanna make sure I got this right. "ASS", automatic instant suspension with 0 human review. "King's Throne: Game of Lust.", with advertised gameplay content such as "I, [the King], shall interrogate this female prisoner privately in my bed chambers", is one of the top advertised games on google play. Got it.

ehehe, sex
Post reply on HN