Live data from Hacker News

Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

techdirt.com

31–40 of 101 posts

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#31
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I loved your reaction. But this isn't about your attitude, this is about far more serious things: Beer. Leaving Germany for good end of this month and - well.. Israel's beers are f...ing (well, it's kind of on topic with your app, isn't it?) baaad. So my choice in the future, after being spoiled in a country of beer drinkers, is * Local brand starts with G (Ugh...) * Local brand starts with M (Really. Life's too shor…

You can get Weihanstephaner in Germany. You shouldn't, but you can.

Don't the Bavarians have a beer-research facility in Weihenstephan?

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#32

Although I find this fantastic, I also find it quite odd? I think his attitude is fantastic for someone who is having their apps ripped off, I find it strangely odd that in the comments people think this is the attitude that developers are meant to take when their work is ripped off, humbled. I purchase all apps from the app store, I had Cydia but I took the jail break off my phone. I think the 59p - £3 for an app is…

[deleted]

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#33

Although I find this fantastic, I also find it quite odd? I think his attitude is fantastic for someone who is having their apps ripped off, I find it strangely odd that in the comments people think this is the attitude that developers are meant to take when their work is ripped off, humbled. I purchase all apps from the app store, I had Cydia but I took the jail break off my phone. I think the 59p - £3 for an app is…

[deleted]

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#34

Although I find this fantastic, I also find it quite odd? I think his attitude is fantastic for someone who is having their apps ripped off, I find it strangely odd that in the comments people think this is the attitude that developers are meant to take when their work is ripped off, humbled. I purchase all apps from the app store, I had Cydia but I took the jail break off my phone. I think the 59p - £3 for an app is…

[deleted]

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#35

Although I find this fantastic, I also find it quite odd? I think his attitude is fantastic for someone who is having their apps ripped off, I find it strangely odd that in the comments people think this is the attitude that developers are meant to take when their work is ripped off, humbled. I purchase all apps from the app store, I had Cydia but I took the jail break off my phone. I think the 59p - £3 for an app is…

I know this isn't the main point, but Cydia does not offe r pirated apps. Most of the things available in Cydia are independant modifications to the system or a set of standard *nix utilities. Sure, a jailbreak makes piracy possible, but it's not about that. Cydia can't prevent piracy on a jailbroken device, but it does provide strong warnings against it (and, from the best statistics we have, people listen: less than half of the jailbreak users have pirated an app.)

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#36
post #19
post #11

I can't believe this simple, kind of stupid thing I did has gotten so much attention. I also can't believe so many people hate Stella. It's not the greatest beer I've ever had, but it's no bud light.

Europeans think its sewer water, and you have to wear (or be) a wife beater to drink it. North American's think its gold -- At least here in Vancouver, its usually the most expensive thing at the bar and people only buy it if they're really treating themselves. I think it tastes fine (not great, but definitely not bad).

I never had it. But I wonder why someone would want a filtered beer, when there's extra-cloudy stuff available.

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#37
post #27
post #11

I can't believe this simple, kind of stupid thing I did has gotten so much attention. I also can't believe so many people hate Stella. It's not the greatest beer I've ever had, but it's no bud light.

Stella is the beer which snobs love to hate- because it's marketed different in America than Europe. (Note to self- don't ever let your brand fall into that trap) There are few topics as polarizing and annoyingly superficial as which beer is "piss-water" and which beer is "good beer."

Moving into off-topic waters here (Edit: Erm, wrote it and it got quite long. Thought about scrapping it, but it might be either amusing or annoying to read. You judge): I guess I can give a very nice example for these kind of things..

I currently live in Cologne [1] (~1.000.000 people, west Germany) ~40km away from Dusseldorf [2] (~600.000 people, but capital of the state). These cities are the prime examples for rivalry between cities all over Germany. Both are cities that heavily rely on tourism, both are very much into carnival (one of the topics that are discussed to death) and both are _the_ place to be for (different types of..) beer.

Here you get 0.2l (i.e. tiny) glasses of rather light beer, brewed in a way that is even (as far as I know a first!) a protected regional trademark akin to Champagne. You can create it somewhere else, but you cannot use the name (a derivation of the name of the city, Koelsch [3, contains a reference to the rivalry as well]).

Dusseldorf is famous for (larger glasses, 0,3l or 0,5l) stronger (in taste), sweeter and dark beers. Not protected by law, but they are more or less _the_ city for these types of beer.

This leads to a lot of (mostly friendly) discussions like the one you used. In fact, since the local beer here is very light and served in these tiny glasses, ~most~ of Germany compares the 14 different brands of beer here to a kind of 'diluted water'.

It always amuses me (moved here, so I'm kind of an outsider) to see these kinds of discussions and I think like to be reminded (thank you!) that this is a global phenomenon..

1: http://maps.google.de/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=de&...

2: http://maps.google.de/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=de&...

3: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/K%C3%B6lsch_%...

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#38

Fine article, but what's up with the hate against Stella Artois?

It depends where you hail from.

Brits and Americans will drink it because they have a HUGE advertising budget.

The Japanese won't drink it because imported beer is hellishly expensive and Asahi isn't that bad.

The French won't drink it, because wine is much cheaper and much better almost everywhere.

Germans won't drink it, because if you want something better then there's umpteen different domestic beers that are fresher, tastier or sharper. Especially Flensburger.

The Czechs won't drink it because they more or less invented clean, refreshing beers and their domestic beers are the only foreign beers that Germans will admit to being fantastic. Especially Pilsner Urquell.

Belgians won't drink it, because they only like beer that's made from raspberries, blueberries or pansies. I don't know why.

Americans or Brits who don't drink it suffer from 'intensely educated beer drinker' syndrome - sort of a "now you've seen how big the world is, how can you make do with this?" aspect. American and British small breweries are fantastic, alas no huge marketing budget...

This leaves the vast majority of the beer-drinking market to make Stella Artois money hand-over-fist and puzzled at the rest of the world's intolerance. Truth is, it's not that bad - it's just that there are things that taste so much better without the stigma of a huge multi-national faceless corporation ;-)

TL;DR - Something like Windows vs. the rest of the world. The popular choice will always be sneered at by connoisseurs eager to distinguish themselves as educated.

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#39
post #31
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can get Weihanstephaner in Germany. You shouldn't, but you can.

Don't the Bavarians have a beer-research facility in Weihenstephan?

I have no idea. I do know that Weihanstephaner market themselves as the world's oldest brewery. Not the best. The oldest ;-)

Re: Guy Asks For Software Crack, Creator Provides Free App Instead

#40

Although I find this fantastic, I also find it quite odd? I think his attitude is fantastic for someone who is having their apps ripped off, I find it strangely odd that in the comments people think this is the attitude that developers are meant to take when their work is ripped off, humbled. I purchase all apps from the app store, I had Cydia but I took the jail break off my phone. I think the 59p - £3 for an app is…

I'd note that jailbreaking and Cydia are not about piracy or encouraging piracy (they're about much more - tons of people even buy jailbreak-only tweaks/themes/etc. from the Cydia Store). Some percentage of people do find ways to get pirated apps after jailbreaking, but those people have to go out and install additional sources/tools beyond the default Cydia install.

The Cydia founder talked about app piracy in a talk a while ago: http://www.tuaw.com/2010/04/13/360idev-saurik-on-the-mobile-... - it fits in:

"Saurik said that many of the pirates he's dealt with are just kids, no more than teenagers, very smart but with not much solid life experience to speak of. And he said that like children, they were both vengeful (they will give bad reviews and attack developers who attack them), and easily won over -- sometimes, by just sending a nice email, he was able to get a former pirate to cooperate with him or even '...come over to the light side.'"

"The best solution to piracy, he said, was to convert the pirates -- don't disable their app or attack them (because likely, they will simply blame the app rather than learn a lesson), but instead inform them that they're breaking the rules, and give them an easy way to do things right. One app Saurik described simply put a one-time notice in the app that the user was using a pirated version, and saw sales spike when the notice went out."

Post reply on HN