Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 41 posts

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#31
I have a 3.5" OCZ Vertex2 that's being used on a daily basis (with lots of swapping) since Oktober. No problems as of yet.

I've had another one (2.5") in my Macbook since early january. No problems either.

Performance might have degraded, but not that I've noticed.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#32
I had a Super Talent (UltraDrive GX) fail after 2 days and 2 different OCZ Vertex 2 fail each after about 3 months. All of them failed in my trusty MacBook Pro.

I'm now back to good old hard drives, sure it's WAY slower but the current state of SSDs seemed to be a bit too unreliable.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#33
In late 2009 I bought 2 Crucial SSDs for my MacBook Pro, replacing a Seagate HDD that had died after just 5 months (the other one went in the optical bay). They're still working fine after 16+ months, and even if they die now they'll have outlived many of my harddrives (75GXP anyone?).

One is my boot drive, and one is my media drive. SMART reports the boot drive has 78% of its erases left, and the media drive 100% (mostly static data). ~20% erases down after 16 months means if the wear leveling works out, my drive should last another 5 years.

My usage is quite normal - coding work doesn't do very many heavy writes. I have 8 GB RAM, so the swap file doesn't see much usage, but instead there's 8 GB of hibernate file writes whenever I put my laptop to sleep (a couple times a day). Also, there's some background process that hits the drive with ~100 KB of writes every couple of seconds.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#34

I had a Super Talent (UltraDrive GX) fail after 2 days and 2 different OCZ Vertex 2 fail each after about 3 months. All of them failed in my trusty MacBook Pro. I'm now back to good old hard drives, sure it's WAY slower but the current state of SSDs seemed to be a bit too unreliable.

I suspect that there is something wrong with your "trusty" MacBook Pro.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#35
I actually had something like 12 SSD failures in the same machine in about 18 months, including 3 of those being an OCZ Vertex 2 and one Intel X25-M. Failures ranged from working fine to completely failing and not even being recognized the next minute (!), to sudden very very slow read/write and drive errors leading to complete failure. Eventually I talked an Apple genius into replacing the logic board in the cursed MBP (second gen unibody, 15", replaced the hard drive instead of opting for the optical bay) and it's been running smooth with a newer Intel X25-M for 4 months now with similar usage patterns.

The first few failures I wanted to chalk up to SSDs being flaky or my being sent refurb drives, but given that I had so many in the same machine and no problems in any other desktops and laptops I tested SSDs with, I just want to blame the machine.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#36
I bought a 256GB Crucial RealSSD C300 and put it in my MacBook Pro. It failed catastrophically within about a month. Luckily I do an automated full-disk backup to an external drive every night; between that and CrashPlan, I didn't lose any data, and Amazon gave me a full refund on the drive.

I then bought a 240GB OWC Mercury Extreme Pro and put it in the same MBP. It's been running fine for about eight months now.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#37

On my 3rd X25-M. First was a g1 that ceased to be recognized by the OS as a device after 9months, the second was a g2 that had much degraded performance and then started showing many errors, corrupt data and the like so I stopped using it. Just prior it was in a RAID 0 array for a year with another x25m g2 that I pulled apart after degraded perf and had a feeling something like this would happen.I now have a single x…

Any citation that Lion will rev the latest MBP to SATA 3/3?

It wasn't clear to me that this was a software limitation...

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#38

Also had no problems whatsoever with my Intel X-25M, over 1.5 years old now. I've heard a lot of horror stories about other manufacturers, but never met another Intel user who had problems. Supposedly OCZ has gotten much better quality wise, though there are lots of bad reviews for those drives on newegg.

OCZ is mainly using sandforce chipset now... which is is a quantum level leap from the initial jmicron chipset.

A vertex2 or vertexLE is a completely different beast than a vertex1.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#39
post #3

Yes, due to firmware bugs.

I've had an OCZ Vertex for a couple of years now (I got it a few months after they came out), and it's been fantastic ever since. I've also got two Intel 60GB SSDs in RAID0 in my laptop, which have worked flawlessly since day 1. However, I purchased an OCZ Vertex 2 for my parents a few months ago as they were building a new computer. About 2 months went by, then one day -- boom -- computer won't boot anymore. I go ov…

I've given up on hibernate for my macbook+vertex2... however, my battery is decent enough to get me through the day and I charge often.

I haven't noticed much of a difference other than the occasional instance of leaving the laptop on and without power (no autosleep for me).

Dropbox+svn/git make sure I don't lose any code.

Re: Poll: Have you had a SSD fail?

#40
post #11

I had been under the impression that when SSD drives die, write operations start failing but existing data is still readable. Is this wrong?

But was it mountable as a read-only volume? Keep in mind that most operating systems require a writable volume unless they've been specifically configured otherwise (e.g., Knoppix).
Post reply on HN