Live data from Hacker News

Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

livescience.com

31–40 of 226 posts

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#31
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately, yes. The first thing we’re going to do as soon as we fine intelligent alien life is figure out how to kill it. And sadly we’ll have to assume they’re doing the same. An no, settling Mars won’t help. If someone / something can launch an interstellar attack it can certainly attack more than one planet and moon.

Are we though? Universe is huge. Wars on earth are waged over scares resources. If we are capable of reaching aliens would we really be incentivized to fight them while there are so many resources available elsewhere?

Habitable planets are the ultimate scarce resource. Once the earth is full we’ll have to find a way to move and there’s less than 5 good options in this solar system. In time they’ll be full too.

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#32
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are we though? Universe is huge. Wars on earth are waged over scares resources. If we are capable of reaching aliens would we really be incentivized to fight them while there are so many resources available elsewhere?

What if wars were waged for ideological reasons also? Beliefs, cultures etc.

Or just defensively. The US invaded Iraq because they might have had WMDs. Other planets might have WMDs too. And they might think we have WMDs. Doesn’t matter if any of the sides actually do.

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#33
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are we though? Universe is huge. Wars on earth are waged over scares resources. If we are capable of reaching aliens would we really be incentivized to fight them while there are so many resources available elsewhere?

Habitable planets are the ultimate scarce resource. Once the earth is full we’ll have to find a way to move and there’s less than 5 good options in this solar system. In time they’ll be full too.

Who says habitable to us == habitable to hypothetical aliens?

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#35
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are we though? Universe is huge. Wars on earth are waged over scares resources. If we are capable of reaching aliens would we really be incentivized to fight them while there are so many resources available elsewhere?

Habitable planets are the ultimate scarce resource. Once the earth is full we’ll have to find a way to move and there’s less than 5 good options in this solar system. In time they’ll be full too.

If we've got the technology to travel between stars, we've probably also got the tech to leave planets behind entirely, or to terraform, or to adapt ourselves to conditions.

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#36
post #32
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What if wars were waged for ideological reasons also? Beliefs, cultures etc.

Or just defensively. The US invaded Iraq because they might have had WMDs. Other planets might have WMDs too. And they might think we have WMDs. Doesn’t matter if any of the sides actually do.

> The US invaded Iraq because they might have had WMDs.

Be careful not to conflate public justifications with actual motivations.

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#37
>Thank you for visiting this site. Unfortunately we have detected that you might be running custom adblocking scripts or installations that might interfere with the running of the site

Yeah leave the "might" be my problem

https://web.archive.org/web/20201023131014/https://www.lives...

Re: Aliens on 1k nearby stars could see us, new study suggests

#40

I always wondered if they could see us, would they recognize us as something to care about? I see ants on my porch, but they don't really matter much to me.

If you didn't know what ants were already they probably would be interesting
Post reply on HN