Live data from Hacker News

DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

anandtech.com

31–40 of 217 posts

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#31

Will we get performance increases, and how big will they be in the average case, not for some specific codes with low cache hit ratio on large datasets, and attributed solely to bandwidth increases and not architecture IPC improvements?

ddr5 will be useful for some of the high core count desktop cpus we are getting, assuming you run software that uses all those cores!

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#34
post #28
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That reminds me, I was going to buy a PS4.

The PS5 can play PS4 games so it would be a worse financial decision I guess

Depends upon what you pay - certainly the second market will see a surge and drop in prices. If you can tech on top end 5 years later, it's not that bad and sure wallet friendly.

Also factor in that it usually takes a few years until the full potential of a platform it tapped, so the PS4 in it's prime days for games.

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#35
I like what IBM has done with their latest power chip - effectually made the whole memory interface upgradable.

https://www.nextplatform.com/2020/09/03/the-memory-area-netw...

"the shift from dedicated DDR4 memory controllers to Serdes-based, high speed differential signaling mixed with buffer chips on memory modules that can be taught to speak DDR4, DDR5, GDDR6, 3D XPoint, or whatever, is an important shift in system design and one that we think, ultimately, the entire industry will get behind eventually."

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#36
post #15

Will we get performance increases, and how big will they be in the average case, not for some specific codes with low cache hit ratio on large datasets, and attributed solely to bandwidth increases and not architecture IPC improvements?

Depends a lot on your CPU's architecture as well as workloads, how far ahead it prefetches vs how often it's stalled on large memory reads. So it's hard to know. e.g. Zen+ (Ryzen 2000) was seeing 10% in some gaming workloads going from DDR4-2400 to DDR4-3600, but it's much less drastic on Intel CPUs or even Zen 2 (Ryzen 3000) because the memory controller is smarter so the slower RAM is less of a detriment. And then…

The reason Zen1 (and 2) speed up a lot from ram speed increases is because the memory controller speed is tied to ram speed. So when you bump up the ram speed you also bump the memory controller speed, which reduces ram latency and inter-cpu communication latency.

There is no telling what the memory controller -> ram ratio will be with ddr5, the memory controller has speed limits, so you aren't going to get free speed just because the dr5 starts at 4800, because the zen memory controller can't run that fast anyway.

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#37

When will this be available with AMD? I'm currently shopping for a new build, and willing to wait 6 months or so, but beyond that I'm not sure ...

AMD will present its next generation Ryzen CPUs, based on Zen 3, the day after tomorrow, 08.10.2020 [0][1] - maybe we can get more info about DDR5 compatibility already then.

[0]: https://twitter.com/AMDRyzen/status/1312080706739339266?

[1]: https://www.amd.com/en/events/gaming-2020?sf238352749=1&sf23...

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#38
post #35

I like what IBM has done with their latest power chip - effectually made the whole memory interface upgradable. https://www.nextplatform.com/2020/09/03/the-memory-area-netw... "the shift from dedicated DDR4 memory controllers to Serdes-based, high speed differential signaling mixed with buffer chips on memory modules that can be taught to speak DDR4, DDR5, GDDR6, 3D XPoint, or whatever, is an important shift in syste…

Adds a latency hop, which generally can be dealt with by prefetching and larger caches on the CPU side.

There's speculation that AMD is going to do the same - in Zen 2 and later designs the CPU chiplets are coupled with different IO dies depending on the design (Ryzen, Threadripper, Epyc), and swapping out the IO die for one that has support for new/different memory types would less work than taping out a whole new monolithic CPU.

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#39
post #8

I'm happy that I put off upgrading my pc long enough to skip a RAM generation.

I have a 4690K and my RAM is a 32GB EVGA DDR3 ram that I suspect was made by hynix or the other manufacturer of fast rams, that runs at speed up to par with the slowest DDR4 but with DDR3 latency, it is very awesome. I wonder if DDR5 will be fast enough to compensate for the slower latency (or maybe they improved latency this time?) To be honest I didn't felt yet any need to move off my current machine, I would only…

Its 2020 and you're still on a crt?

Re: DDR5 Is Coming: First 64GB DDR5-4800 Modules from SK Hynix

#40
post #34
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The PS5 can play PS4 games so it would be a worse financial decision I guess

Depends upon what you pay - certainly the second market will see a surge and drop in prices. If you can tech on top end 5 years later, it's not that bad and sure wallet friendly. Also factor in that it usually takes a few years until the full potential of a platform it tapped, so the PS4 in it's prime days for games.

I do not understand your argument as the parent post is saying the PS5 can play PS4 games. So the PS5 will also benefit from the great games coming on PS4. The prices of the games would be the same, you would benefit from the same experience of the devs developing on the PS4. The only disadvantage is that the PS5 will be pricer. And it will also be less ecological-friendly if you intend to buy an used PS4. But that's it.
Post reply on HN