Live data from Hacker News

A researcher on how to live a happy life

ox.ac.uk

31–40 of 199 posts

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#32

I often inquire 'why is happiness the thing we choose to focus on'

I do too; I've had this conversation a few times. Happiness isn't my highest priority, it's up there, but there's a lot of trade temporary happiness for, such as health or sanity.

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#33
post #25

I have concerns about following advice people write about how to be happy. Why are they doing it? Is it because they are happy, and they want to spread it? If so, is it like a rich person writing on how to become rich? Maybe they tell you X,Y,Z that they think were important in becoming rich, but it was actually A,B,C that they were blind to. The worse alternative is if it is someone who was unhappy, and then did som…

Yet, even so, the advice they give can still be true. It may be that they just want to help others and also in the process help themselves.

The advices given in the article ring true to me, so it really felt like reading something I already "know" but just don't practice often enough. I find it useful to be reminded.

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#34

I think these are bad tips to be honest. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy - really? People in countries where psychotherapy is not as prevalent as in the US aren't necessarily unhappier I think. Some occupations have earned their bad reputation. My opinion. I am not happy with it, but generally quite happy I believe. I don't feel too happy about changing my prejudice towards this field. Appreciation of what you have is…

I’d encourage you to reconsider the article in context of the fact that CBT can be self-taught with no books or sessions - all of this advice is free, and each tip works independently of the others. I do agree that open-ended talk therapy seems like a waste of time.

Open-ended talk therapy is like rubber duck debugging. Sometimes you need an expressive outlet that you can't, for various reasons, find elsewhere. And often a confidant (which a therapist can be) is what you need. Lacking a confidant in normal-life or having issues you feel you can't take to that person, a therapist is a decent alternative.

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#36

Happiness is not an ideal. Happiness is tepid water on the tongue. -- Holderlin Man does not desire happiness. Only the Englishman does. -- Nietzsche

In haven't read Nietzsche, but any time I read a quote of his, it always seems to appeal to the most power hungry part of my ego.

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#37
So if you ask people if they’d be happier living in California or the Midwest, most people say California. Actually the regions have comparable life satisfaction, but people say California because they think of the weather and fail to take account of other things, such as the fact that California is full of tedious hippies.

The author does not cite research about about how "tedious hippies" make people sad, nor demographic evidence that California is "full of" them.

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#39
post #37

So if you ask people if they’d be happier living in California or the Midwest, most people say California. Actually the regions have comparable life satisfaction, but people say California because they think of the weather and fail to take account of other things, such as the fact that California is full of tedious hippies. The author does not cite research about about how "tedious hippies" make people sad, nor demog…

I think it might be a joke.

Re: A researcher on how to live a happy life

#40

I have long regarded happiness in the same category as grace: it is an undeserved and unasked for free gift. An epiphenomena that is not a consequence of, but happens along with, other positive actions. And for me that's living a less self-centered life. I am happy when what I do with my life enriches the lives of others. But being transactional about this ruins the game. It is, among other things, the opposite of ze…

This pretty much sums up Christian ethics.
Post reply on HN