Live data from Hacker News

Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

nimbleindustries.io

31–40 of 149 posts

Re: Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

#31
post #25

What I don't get is how they can be down for hours on end. If I make a deploy that turns out to be buggy, I'll roll my site back to a stable previous version within minutes. Sure, that's not always possible if I've made incompatible database schema changes, but in my experience those are very, very rare (i.e. I almost always add db columns, and only rarely delete or rename columns - and when I do, I do so after those…

> If I make a deploy that turns out to be buggy

Unless your deploy reconfigures some networking component that makes a large part of your network inaccessible. Then you need to fix the network issue before you can rollback to a previous version. That may require someone driving up to a datacenter and logging into a racked server.

And then you may need to restore data if the network misconfiguration caused data to be corrupted somehow (I admit this is getting a bit worst-possible-case-scenario) and, if the data got crossed - that one client could see data from another - you'll need to prevent access until you are sure everything is where it should be.

Finally, depending on your scale, the deploy of a new version can take a long time by itself. People often deploy new features deactivated, then, when the whole fleet is updated, activate features to different groups and monitor for breaking behavior change.

Re: Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

#32
post #25

What I don't get is how they can be down for hours on end. If I make a deploy that turns out to be buggy, I'll roll my site back to a stable previous version within minutes. Sure, that's not always possible if I've made incompatible database schema changes, but in my experience those are very, very rare (i.e. I almost always add db columns, and only rarely delete or rename columns - and when I do, I do so after those…

I'm sure these down times are more about infrastructure problems than just database updates and I'm also sure that this infrastructure is a little more complexe than your site.

Re: Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

#35
I'm more inclined to believe this is due to the increased reporting and attention to the status rather than an actual increase in downtime.

However, I have no hard data to suggest that, only my experience as someone who's had to manage and maintain reports like this.

Re: Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

#36

I really wish there was an option to decouple the core git functionality from the 'fancy' stuff (PRs, actions, issues) etc. When your CI pipeline runs directly from your git repository, not being able to commit/merge means you cannot release to production. For binary artifacts, you can get around dependencies on a single provider by mirroring, but because git is mutable, you can't just mirror the repo and allow chang…

That is exactly how GitHub is architectured. There have been a lot of time I've been to able to push/pull but GitHub pages was down or their web backend was down.

Bitbucket is the worst in this regard.

Re: Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

#37
post #24
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Personally, I'd prefer some availability over sparkly features.

Not counting the redesign, there haven't been "sparkly" features. Sparkly features are the kinds of things the old management used to let engineers have free reign to implement. Github pre-Microsoft was rudderless. They were more prone to implementing silly 3d model diff tools and things instead of supporting enterprise features or building powerful CI/CD tools and automation. New Github is on the right track.

- Personal Status

- Round Avatars (all catgirl ears are now cut off)

- Collapsing of some similar messages on the Dashboard into one (i missed some things because of this)

- Not just one, but several redesigns (im old)

- The whole "marketplace" functionality (imitation of an app store)

- The "explore" and "trending" functionality (i see this like a Facebook feed)

Not sure about others, but i used GitHub as a git host and issue/MR tracker. All the other stuff is just distraction in my eyes.

Re: Has GitHub been down more since its acquisition by Microsoft?

#38
What’s really wonderful is when Github goes down I get a flurry of people broadcasting on Slack channels that they can’t work and all their builds are failing, and I’m wondering What they want me to do about it. Should I get out and push? Call Bill Gates? Tweet Trump? When Github doesn’t work that’s your excuse to go get coffee, grab a pint, browse Hacker News, etc. - people should be happy with GitHub goes down. (Or self-host gitea and work from that if your so determined to keep on)
Post reply on HN