Live data from Hacker News

Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

bloomberg.com

31–40 of 78 posts

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#31
post #8

Apple is here making an ultra-aggressive attempt at a land grab in the world of application software. The mark granted to it is for "App Store". Under relevant trademark law, a mark cannot be registered if it consists solely of a generic or purely descriptive term. "Store" is generic. So too is the word "application" - which is commonly thought of as being what the word "app" refers to. Therefore, no trademark could…

[deleted]

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#32
post #8

Apple is here making an ultra-aggressive attempt at a land grab in the world of application software. The mark granted to it is for "App Store". Under relevant trademark law, a mark cannot be registered if it consists solely of a generic or purely descriptive term. "Store" is generic. So too is the word "application" - which is commonly thought of as being what the word "app" refers to. Therefore, no trademark could…

Could Apple argue that customers might think they are buying from Apple, when in fact they are buying from Amazon?

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#33
post #23

Today's News Summary: Apple = Trademark Troll Microsoft = Patent Troll AT&T = Monopoly If Amazon fights this they could win and it could be good news for everyone, except Apple. p.s. Yes I know Amazon is a patent troll as well.

Trolls trolling trolls. As always.

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#34
post #21
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your question is a very good one. A term that is primarily descriptive cannot be registered as a trademark on the primary register with the USPTO. However, if a vendor spends a lot in advertising over a substantial time such that the public comes to identify the relevant term with one vendor and not as a primarily descriptive term, then that item is said to acquire "secondary meaning." Once a primarily descriptive te…

Apple has successfully promoted the heck out of name "App Store" and spent a fortune doing so. If that's the criteria they have a solid case.

I don't know if that should matter. If Facebook spends billions promoting it's brand and then sues people making books with faces who called it, lets say Staunch's face book, I don't see how they deserve to win.

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#35
post #8

Apple is here making an ultra-aggressive attempt at a land grab in the world of application software. The mark granted to it is for "App Store". Under relevant trademark law, a mark cannot be registered if it consists solely of a generic or purely descriptive term. "Store" is generic. So too is the word "application" - which is commonly thought of as being what the word "app" refers to. Therefore, no trademark could…

"Windows" is a trademark ( http://www.microsoft.com/about/legal/en/us/IntellectualPrope... ), so how do you explain that? If windows is not a generic word, it must be because it's applied in a specific context (a window manager). So then, possibly an "app store" doesn't just mean a store on Main St, that happens to have applications on its shelves, but a novel concept worthy of a trademark?

First of all "Windows" itself doesn't mean an OS. You can argue that OSes have generic GUI windows, but Microsoft is not suing to prevent Gnome from calling itself a window manager with application windows. "Windows" is a trademark for an operating system.

>So then, possibly an "app store" doesn't just mean a store on Main St, that happens to have applications on its shelves, but a novel concept worthy of a trademark?

Well, store doesn't really mean only physical stores right? There are a bunch of online shops calling themselves stores from the 90s.

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#37
Click on our website:

---------- http://www.fullmalls.com ---------

---------- http://www.fullmalls.com ---------

We can supply all kind jersey with good quality and low price. contact me, let’s talk details.

Delivery time: 5-6days, Shipping Method: EMS

Newest stock list: every 3-5days updated

Air jordan (1-24) shoes $33

UGG BOOT $50

Nike Shox (R4,NZ,OZ,TL1,TL2,TL3) $35

Handbags (Coach ,LV ,Fendi ,D&G) $35

Tshirts (Polo ,ED Hardy,Lacoste) $16

Jean (True Religion,ED Hardy,Coogi) $30

Sunglasses (Oakey,Coach,Gucci,A rmaini) $16

New era cap $15

Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $25

FREE SHIPPING

---------- http://www.fullmalls.com ---------

---------- http://www.fullmalls.com ---------

Re: Apple Sues Amazon.com, Seeks Order to Stop Use of 'App Store'

#38
Click on our website:

---------- http://www.fullmalls.com ---------

We can supply all kind jersey with good quality and low price. contact me, let’s talk details.

Delivery time: 5-6days, Shipping Method: EMS

Newest stock list: every 3-5days updated

Air jordan (1-24) shoes $33

UGG BOOT $50

Nike Shox (R4,NZ,OZ,TL1,TL2,TL3) $35

Handbags (Coach ,LV ,Fendi ,D&G) $35

Tshirts (Polo ,ED Hardy,Lacoste) $16

Jean (True Religion,ED Hardy,Coogi) $30

Sunglasses (Oakey,Coach,Gucci,A rmaini) $16

New era cap $15

Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $25

FREE SHIPPING

---------- http://www.fullmalls.com ---------

Post reply on HN