Live data from Hacker News

Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

kevq.uk

31–40 of 552 posts

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#31
post #12

Personally I like dark mode for macOS/iOS windows, menus etc... but light mode inside apps / on websites for reading text such as blogs, ebooks and emails.

I also use light mode on a Mac, as I hate the reflections in dark mode. If there's a nonreflective display though, it's dark mode all the way.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#32
I just use the mode that works better in different applications.

I prefer sepia background for reader mode and ebooks. Night themes always for text editors.

It also matters a lot on when the room is brightly lit or not.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#34
post #5

They taught us this in advertising. White text scatters over the iris on a dark background, so it’s harder to read the copy. I’ve even read it in UX articles. It was amusing to get out of school and into the tech industry to find dark mode everywhere. Granted, I use it too. Both my terminal and editor have dark themes. I’m not really sure why. The terminal isn’t really a big deal to me. I could go either way there. B…

For a light color theme with a slightly different take than usual, I would recommend Flatwhite.

The differentiating idea behind it is that for dark syntax themes, it makes sense to have the foreground of text be different colors. In contrast, for light syntax themes, it makes sense to have the background of text be different colors.

Atom: https://github.com/biletskyy/flatwhite-syntax Sublime Text 3: https://github.com/Willamin/flatwhite

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#35
post #24
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ll admit it’s not the best phrasing (and I’m definitely not an ophthalmologist, so I’m playing fast and loose here). Your pupils dilate to let in more light because there’s less light overall when the background is black. This causes your lens to distort slightly, thus making the edges of the white text appear to be fuzzy or bleed into surrounding characters. I couldn’t find a scientific source on this, but a coupl…

>[...] This causes your lens to distort slightly, thus making the edges of the white text appear to be fuzzy or bleed into surrounding characters The effect you're describing is correct, but the mechanism isn't. Aperture (pupil) size directly affects how focused the image is. The smaller the aperture, the sharper the image is. As an extreme example, if your aperture is a single point (a pinhole camera), the image can…

> Articles describing this seems to say it's caused by the film medium, rather than being an optical effect.

Yeah, I noticed that. Searching the term directly gave me results related to film, but when I used other terms describing the effect they mentioned it in a different context. Makes me wonder if someone is just confused.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#36

> I’ve decided to stop using dark mode across all of my devices, because research suggests that going to the dark side ain’t all that. It makes sense to use research to make a decision that is based on data that applies equally across a population. But for something that is a personal preference, it doesn't make as much sense to rely on population-level data. If you started using dark mode because you liked it, then…

I use dark mode IDEs exclusively because light mode ones remind me of my early experiences with Eclipse, Ant builds, and horrible enterprise Java. Which just isn’t something I want to think about when I’m working on projects that I enjoy.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#37

> I’ve decided to stop using dark mode across all of my devices, because research suggests that going to the dark side ain’t all that. It makes sense to use research to make a decision that is based on data that applies equally across a population. But for something that is a personal preference, it doesn't make as much sense to rely on population-level data. If you started using dark mode because you liked it, then…

Exactly. That's like saying research suggests that the average person fits best into a medium size T-shirt, so that's best T-shirt for me.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#38

No one seems to be mentioning the lighting of the room you're in, inside/outside, or the time of day. Ambient light is one of the primary factors that make light or dark mode better at a particular moment. See redshift to make light mode more tolerable at night.

Yeah, I'm not sure you can say anything meaningful about eye strain and readability without accounting for room lighting, glare, and other reflective surfaces and distractions. If I'm in a dark room with a bright screen, it's almost physically painful to stare at the screen. I have to turn the brightness way down, and then I lose contrast and have to strain even more. In an office with horrible flourescent lighting,…

If you're using a monitor with separate brightness and contrast settings, you might also choose to lower the contrast a bit. When my monitor's contrast is at 75%, white doesn't really get less bright until somewhere around 30% brightness. But I'd I lower contrast to 50%, then 50% brightness makes a bigger difference, without losing readability.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#39
A lot of visual professional apps tend to be color neutral so you don't bias your work. Whether for trendiness or for functional reasons they also all tend to use darker colors for their UI. This seems to extend to audio apps, too. For color-accurate work ambient light is lowered (windows are covered and walls tend to be painted neutral). Even Photoshop transitioned to a darker-and-darker UI between CS4-CS6 (~2015).

It's really jarring when spending hours inside these apps and jump to a file browser or web browser and get blasted with light.

Re: Is Dark Mode Such a Good Idea?

#40
>In fact, this very site that you’re on right now automagically flips to dark mode if you’re that way inclined.

It does not come up that way for me. I'm on OSX with appearance set to dark. (Firefox 77.0.1)

Is there something I'm doing wrong? YC is a light theme too.

Post reply on HN