Live data from Hacker News

Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

wsj.com

31–40 of 82 posts

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#31
post #20

If anybody is interested I have a database of roughly 4B IPv4 addresses for sale:)

Could you please remove mine under article 17 of the GDPR? :D

Hmm, GDPR thought experiment: I make a database of public IPv4s by running a couple for-loops and subtracting private spaces. Can an EU guy who owns an IPv4 request to have it removed?

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#33
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This seems like a bit of an over reach no? I've looked up wire fraud in the US and it seems to come with some properly serious penalties: Whoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television communication i…

No? The use of deception to obtain something of value that would not otherwise be given to you is the literal, legal definition of fraud?

So, where does that leave advertising? The entire purpose of advertising is to get somebody to spend money on a product they otherwise wouldn't have.

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If he misrepresented himself in order to gain a financial advantage then that is fraud. Creating shell companies is not illegal, using a name fir yourself that isn’t your legal name is not illegal, doing either of those things in order to trick people into giving you money is.

Not just financial advantage, all deceit where you intend to gain from it is fraud. Money just makes it more obvious what the gain was. Are there grey areas? Sure. In particular there's a passive sort of deceit in which you let people assume things that you know aren't true, to your benefit. Mostly the law holds that it's their mistake for not asking, and anyway they'd usually be far too embarrassed to make a fuss if…

> all deceit where you intend to gain from it is fraud

Except if you're a magician, of course!

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#35
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No? The use of deception to obtain something of value that would not otherwise be given to you is the literal, legal definition of fraud?

So, where does that leave advertising? The entire purpose of advertising is to get somebody to spend money on a product they otherwise wouldn't have.

“The use of deception” is key, and it’s true that advertising often crosses the line, and should be prosecuted more often.

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was done to deceive ARIN which is why it is being considered wire fraud.

This seems like a bit of an over reach no? I've looked up wire fraud in the US and it seems to come with some properly serious penalties: Whoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television communication i…

“Not more than”. For most crimes the sentencing guidelines are broad so the context of the case may be taken into account by the judge and/or jury.

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#37

Hmm. I "obtained" 2^32 IPv4 addresses pretty easily; not sure if it's legitimate or not: for addr in range(2**32): print('.'.join([str(addr >> (i Edit: Well, this was unpopular. In case it's too subtle, my point is that the title is terrible.

The concept of ownership of an IP address, implied by “obtains”, is pretty clear and well-understood. The story was exactly what I imagined after reading the headline. Rather than making an obtuse joke, how would you suggest it be improved?

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#38
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's nothing wrong with the title. Obtained means "To get hold of; to gain possession of, to procure; to acquire, in any way".

Which is quite literally what my script does :) Think about if the title said "800K email addresses obtained illegitimately", and what you would interpret the meaning of that to be.

I would expect a database of valid email addresses had been compromised. Context of what is being “obtained” matters, of course. But the sum total of valid IP addresses is a fixed, finite, and well-known value. Can you write a script to generate all valid email addresses?

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#39
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No? The use of deception to obtain something of value that would not otherwise be given to you is the literal, legal definition of fraud?

So, where does that leave advertising? The entire purpose of advertising is to get somebody to spend money on a product they otherwise wouldn't have.

You going to work also serves the purpose "to get somebody to [give you] money they otherwise wouldn't have". So that definition is obviously too broad, and different from the definition of fraud mentioned above.

Advertisement tends to deal in opinions, not facts. And where specific factual claims are made against better knowledge it does constitute fraud, and is occasionally prosecuted. See Volkswagen's emissions claims, for example. Or, just this week, some hand sanitiser got hit by the FDA for claiming protection against Ebola and Coronavirus.

Re: Prosecutors allege Micfo obtained 800k IPv4 addresses illegally

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A prosecution seems a bit over the top for this... Setting up multiple companies to meet some rule isnt against said rule. And anyway, it's a company policy not the law.

It was done to deceive ARIN which is why it is being considered wire fraud.

if shell companies are fraud, much of the economy is in trouble
Post reply on HN