Live data from Hacker News

Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

blog.plaid.com

31–40 of 63 posts

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#31
post #29

Does anyone know if European SEPA actually overlap with Plaid here ? Was SEPA supposed to "commoditize" the whole "grant access to my bank account to 3rdparty" ?

No (AFAIK), SEPA is meant for facilitate bank transfers (cashless payments) across the members of SEPA. Basically taking the fragmented system across Europe and try to unify it under something to make things easier across the region.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#32

Can someone pls ELI5 how Plaid, Yodlee, AuthLayer are valid businesses and not hit with regulatory hurdles? They seem to be scraping bank websites behind the scenes. Whilst I have no idea abt the US/EU market, I know for a fact that most banks do charge exorbitant fees to access accounts over APIs (esp if you're a BigCo and need that kind of control). Surely, the banks can't be happy abt that? Surprising they haven't…

Per PSD2, the banks have to offer APIs. It’s already possible in Europe to see your balances from another bank on your primary banks app

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I came across Plaid for the first time today and when trying to make a transfer through Transferwise. When asked for my bank username and password at a website !my_bank I was like hell nope. Ended up having to use a credit card instead which had the highest fee... :( I hope this kind of garbage disappears.

I would rather have entered my logins and then changed the password if I was that concerned about entering my bank logins rather than pay those credit card fees. Or change the password first, login, and change back to your old password.

They can pull all go your transactions in that time, changing your password after is still too late.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#34
Developers should refuse to use Plaid. Plaid abuses its account privileges and takes much more than it gives the users. For instance, Carta should never need Plaid to pull every transaction from a bank account just to let someone exercise stock options.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#35
For those who have used Plaid for personal projects, can someone confirm if you can pull basic monthly stats by account for all account types, including cash, debt (CC/mortgage), and assets (investment accounts, etc.), and then net worth and net income, all while on the free or pay as you go plans?

It appears from the docs that I'd need to pay $500/mo for very basic stats for anything not cash account balance related which is not feasible for my personal use.

My current alternative is Mint which is really lacking in the "automating my own spreadsheet with the data" department.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#36
Something I've always worried about: if I provide my bank's login credentials to a service which uses Plaid/Yodlee and due to a security breach my bank account is somehow drained, who's liable? Most banks explicitly state that losses due to sharing of credentials are not protected by their fraud guarantees. Are customers at risk by using Plaid?

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#37

Something I've always worried about: if I provide my bank's login credentials to a service which uses Plaid/Yodlee and due to a security breach my bank account is somehow drained, who's liable? Most banks explicitly state that losses due to sharing of credentials are not protected by their fraud guarantees. Are customers at risk by using Plaid?

Same question here. I wonder if Plaid has an official answer on this.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#38
What is Plaid's long-term competitive advantage? It made sense when scraping was the only solution (albeit an extremely dangerous one) but now banks are launching their own APIs, which is allowing some competitors to come in with free bank account linking. A few simple features address most of the needs of a typical fintech, and I don't think anyone is happy with having to integrate Plaid's SDK nor pay their rates.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#39

For those who have used Plaid for personal projects, can someone confirm if you can pull basic monthly stats by account for all account types, including cash, debt (CC/mortgage), and assets (investment accounts, etc.), and then net worth and net income, all while on the free or pay as you go plans? It appears from the docs that I'd need to pay $500/mo for very basic stats for anything not cash account balance related…

pocketsmith (https://www.pocketsmith.com/) is a pretty good solution for this. I was a Mint user that was concerned about the privacy and also looking for a service that provided an API. I'm not 100% sure about the privacy, but they do provide an API for your own financial data.

Re: Plaid Launches in France, Spain, and Ireland

#40
post #6

I've been using Plaid for a toy project for a while, and, while it works well, what surprised me the most was their support. I had an issue with my bank not sending me SMS and their support was quick and helpful, responding to my problem with actual feedback rather than canned responses. Now that I'm saying this, I realize what a low bar our current support climate has set, but Plaid is great on that regardless.

Would something like this address your sms finance communications? https://www.asktrim.com/ I use it to get notifications on charges and I can check my balance.
Post reply on HN