Live data from Hacker News

Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

status.cloud.google.com

31–40 of 57 posts

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#31
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Says something that they know the what , where , when , and why , but the still don't (or won't) prevent it.

It's a matter of cost. It's a temporary spike of traffic far outside of average use. In order to handle it, they'd need a lot of resources that just aren't justifiable for the rest of the year. You seem similar things when places sell highly desired items in online stores.

They're a bleeding cloud provider. I think they can temporarily scale up a bit.

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#32
post #20
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also, summer interns. A friend who worked at FB said outages there go up markedly when interns start pushing to prod.

> interns start pushing to prod hey everybody, I spotted the problem! I'll keep an eye on my mailbox for the giant consulting fee that I assume is enroute.

[deleted]

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#34

Just as I was implementing and testing high-priority Google SSO changes at work... it goes down :-)

You broke Google. I hope you feel good about yourself.

Better now when you can test your error handling then at 3:30am when your high priority service goes down :)

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#36
Disclosure: Former Googler

I didn't think I would laugh that hard coming in here and reading these comments, but here we are. I can virtually guarantee that the following things are not the root of the problem:

* Lack of compute/networking/storage

* Incompetence of employees

* Back to school traffic spikes

* Just about anything else here

My $0.02. these are almost always due to bad roll outs, usually configuration changes. But I've been wrong countless times before!

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#37
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a matter of cost. It's a temporary spike of traffic far outside of average use. In order to handle it, they'd need a lot of resources that just aren't justifiable for the rest of the year. You seem similar things when places sell highly desired items in online stores.

They're a bleeding cloud provider. I think they can temporarily scale up a bit.

Temporarily build a data center?

Temporarily shut down other people's services to favor their own?

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#38

Disclosure: Former Googler I didn't think I would laugh that hard coming in here and reading these comments, but here we are. I can virtually guarantee that the following things are not the root of the problem: * Lack of compute/networking/storage * Incompetence of employees * Back to school traffic spikes * Just about anything else here My $0.02. these are almost always due to bad roll outs, usually configuration ch…

Thanks for the reassuring note that google is still a hegemonic super power. Almost spilled my kool aid

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe memorising algorithms from a textbook does not translate to great system engineering and SRE skills? Who would have thought.

I'm glad you have a good handle on the data about the predictive power Google interviews have about the individuals. Can you share the data?

I have a good handle on how the customer base for cloud computing services perceives cloud vendors and aws is way ahead of everyone else by a mile.

This is because they have a far better and complete platform, and it appears to be better engineered too with fewer of the downtime incidents we’ve been seeing at the other vendors.

Why do you suspect this is? Let me tell you. Amazon had better people. Full stop.

Re: Google OAuth Is Failing with 500 Error Code

#40

Disclosure: Former Googler I didn't think I would laugh that hard coming in here and reading these comments, but here we are. I can virtually guarantee that the following things are not the root of the problem: * Lack of compute/networking/storage * Incompetence of employees * Back to school traffic spikes * Just about anything else here My $0.02. these are almost always due to bad roll outs, usually configuration ch…

"these are almost always due to bad roll outs, usually configuration changes." Some would consider that falling under #2. (Not me though)
Post reply on HN