Live data from Hacker News

0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

0x.org

31–40 of 209 posts

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#31
post #7

I'd perhaps add something like 'crypto' to the headline - I thought this was a marketplace for physical items, somehow - like a local goods exchange.

OK, added. Thanks! We could also try “token”, which seems more precise in context although more ambiguous on its own.

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#32

This looks great but I'm not sure if the title is accurate. For most of the world the barrier to running an exchange is four fold: 1. Technology 2. Regulatory 3. Trust 4. Critical mass This looks like it only address 1. Which is certainly a big hurdle but I would have loved to seen something explaining how to get 2 - 4 done. From some of the answers bellow: > You don't have to trust! 0x Exchanges are non-custodial Th…

I think you forgot: 0. Doesn't actually solve any real problem for actual humans in the first place.

That's an extremely short-sighted and ignorant comment. I would figure you, as someone who is a well-respected technologist, wouldn't be so flippant and would have more vision.

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#33
post #17

Why should I launch an exchange when there are already hundreds of existing exchange? As a entrepreneur: Exchange services is very difficult to differentiate. It’s a commodity service. Why should I invest in marketing to promote my new exchange? As a customer: Why should I buy tokens? - Most of existing tokens have not active project behind - Many times the token is useless for the project and it will not increase in…

If you want to list the same assets as everyone else with the same interface in the same markets, then yes, it's hard to compete. However, we see a world of tokenized assets coming online that will need unique markets for exchange. Something like Radar Relay (https://radarrelay.com/ for ERC-20 commodities) is totally different from Veil (https://veil.co/ for prediction market shares) is totally different from BoxSwap (https://boxswap.io/ for trading collectibles). Even within ERC-20 commodities exchange, there are many different models of exchange within different markets that are sufficiently differentiated.

We think of 0x more like Stripe: an under-the-hood technology that allows entrepreneurs to move more quickly and easily add exchange to their product. The concept of "tokens" and "exchange" will become very abstract in the near future.

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#34
post #17

Why should I launch an exchange when there are already hundreds of existing exchange? As a entrepreneur: Exchange services is very difficult to differentiate. It’s a commodity service. Why should I invest in marketing to promote my new exchange? As a customer: Why should I buy tokens? - Most of existing tokens have not active project behind - Many times the token is useless for the project and it will not increase in…

Different jurisdictions have different compliance requirements. Not sure, but my guess is the goal of this project is to allow regulatory arbitrage with a single unified interface.

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#35
post #17

Why should I launch an exchange when there are already hundreds of existing exchange? As a entrepreneur: Exchange services is very difficult to differentiate. It’s a commodity service. Why should I invest in marketing to promote my new exchange? As a customer: Why should I buy tokens? - Most of existing tokens have not active project behind - Many times the token is useless for the project and it will not increase in…

Answering why is up to you, the builder; differentiation is key to why 0x has created this protocol.

"Tokens" can be a special kind of object which can be "exchanged" for other kinds of objects. It is not always about purchasing or swapping; this interaction can solve many different kinds of coordination problems.

The exchange can create a context around users interacting via various types of tokens, enabling new kinds of services and communities to form. This could lead to enormous value for users.

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#36
post #19

Tom from 0x here. Happy to answer any questions about Launch Kit or 0x more broadly!

Hi Tom! After reading the Why page, I still don't have a concrete notion of what this is. So I'll jab a few questions that might help me make some sense: First question is about decentralization. What is off-chain relay in this case? Is that a centralized part of the system? Are there centralized parts of the system? Can this be used to implement more robust margin trading? To my knowledge, only centralized exchanges…

Great questions!

First question is about decentralization. What is off-chain relay in this case? Is that a centralized part of the system? Are there centralized parts of the system?

Off-chain relay is how parties find each other facilitate a trade. As a maker, I can create an order off-chain, but I still need to find a relevant taker who is interested in filling the order by sending it to the 0x smart contracts on-chain. Relayers pool together these off-chain orders and serve them up through a website, so that it's easy to find people to trade with. Note that this process is optional -- you can still trade peer-to-peer if I send you the order over email, SMS, etc. While relaying is centralized, relayers are non-custodial, so your funds are never at risk. We also have plans to make some parts of relaying less centralized in the future through 0x Mesh: https://blog.0xproject.com/0x-roadmap-2019-part-3-networked-...

Can this be used to implement more robust margin trading?

As for margin trading, yes, you can trade dY/dX tokens on 0x relayers, or combine 0x orders with any on-chain lending protocol such as Dharma or MakerDAO to get leverage.

What settlement speeds can be expected?

All trades currently settle on-chain, so the Ethereum block time is our bottleneck. Look for some updates on this near future :)

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#37
post #17

Why should I launch an exchange when there are already hundreds of existing exchange? As a entrepreneur: Exchange services is very difficult to differentiate. It’s a commodity service. Why should I invest in marketing to promote my new exchange? As a customer: Why should I buy tokens? - Most of existing tokens have not active project behind - Many times the token is useless for the project and it will not increase in…

>> Why should I launch an exchange when there are already hundreds of existing exchange?

Maybe you have the on-off ramps sorted out, a friendly bank and a regulatory environment, licenses, legitimate AML/KYC measures and can do it properly?

While there are many exchanges already, how many can say they're that above board?

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#38
When 0x was conceived, there were far fewer crytocurrency exchanges than there are today. It aimed to solve a real problem that still exists in some ways.

Since 0x is a blockchain project, it has moved at a snail's pace compared to the multitude of centralized and web-based "decentralized" exchanges that have sprung up since. These newer exchanges have largely solved the needs identified by 0x.

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#39

When 0x was conceived, there were far fewer crytocurrency exchanges than there are today. It aimed to solve a real problem that still exists in some ways. Since 0x is a blockchain project, it has moved at a snail's pace compared to the multitude of centralized and web-based "decentralized" exchanges that have sprung up since. These newer exchanges have largely solved the needs identified by 0x.

[deleted]

Re: 0x Launch Kit – Launch your own cryptocurrency exchange or marketplace

#40

Does the planet _really_ need any more crypto exchanges? Hardly a week goes by without a couple of new ones starting. Surely we must have more than enough by now?

Hardly a week goes by without one folding due to hacking, mismanagement, or outright criminal activity. Seems like they need someone to keep up the churn or they might run low.

So, no. The answer is no.

EDIT: it's absurd that people continue to fall for this nonsense, but here we are, I guess.

Post reply on HN