Live data from Hacker News

Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

blog.joinmastodon.org

31–40 of 89 posts

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#31
post #12

I feel like "BlurHash" is a misleading name, since it's not a hash of the image data that gets created, it's just highly compressed to just some data about the colours used. Unless I'm misunderstanding something?

You could say that hash is a very aggressive, lossy compression.

Same image will result in same hash. Different images will often result in different hashes. That makes it a valid hash.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#32
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It works in german. "tröten", also the original developer is from germany.

Social communications software is all about the number of users. It needs to able to catch on everywhere. A term that sounds embarassing to many of its potential users is a real problem.

As a modestly funded project, Mastodon is never going to achieve "hockey stick" growth, and it would probably be overwhelmed if this happened. It's better for them to pursue a strategy of gradual, steady growth. Mastodon is continuing to grow steadily, and it does so in the face of established players who can outspend and outrun them. 2 million users is pretty damn good for an open source project that doesn't have a marketing budget to speak of.

In addition, it's time to drop the notion that every platform has to serve every type of user. As demonstrated by the problems facing Twitter, it is probably better to have many different platforms serving different audiences. Mass media inevitably reaches for the lowest common denominator.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#33
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Twitter = cute birds chirping at each other to communicate Mastodon = extinct elephant-like mammal This is why successful companies hire marketers.

What's not cute about elephants? Especially fluffy ones?

"Extinct" is not really a good idea to associate your brand with.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#34

How does Mastodon handle governance for content that gets reported? It sounds like a logistics nightmare. It's nice that the apps are getting a way to blur things, but I would imagine that the bigger problem would be bad actors running instances, and finding ways to keep them away.

Mastodon doesn't. It's the software. Instance (server) administrators and moderators choose to handle reports.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#35
post #29
post #4

I really like the idea of Mastodon, but i can't shake this feeling that their name is kind of awful. I get that they're not trying to be exactly like twitter but by comparison, twitter is a much bubblier and friendlier word.

Better than cockroachdb but not exactly a noteworthy brand name.

It depends on who's being marketed to.

If CockroachDB was being sold to the average person, it'd be an awful name from a branding perspective.

In reality, it's being sold to nerds who probably aren't as off-put by the name and are more interested in what it does as a database. To hit the point home, the database is designed with resilience in mind, just like actual cockroaches!

For something being marketed to the masses, Mastodon isn't great branding. Nobody thinks of Mastodons when thinking of any form of communication, but we all hear birds tweeting every day and have been used in real life to send messages. When asking people to think of something "cute", nobody is going to say "a mastodon". The term "tweet" is considered cute and inoffensive. But "toot"? Most people I know associate that word with flatulence.

Maybe the use of the word "toot" is an subtle admission that most of what people will say on social media is basically shit?

I'm sorry, but nerdy programmers who work on open source are terrible at marketing and have been so since time immemorial. If they could have simply named their software better, they might have had a shot at a "Year of the Linux Desktop". It's like they forget that most people aren't geeks, and then they wonder why the general public doesn't [knowingly] use any of their stuff.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#36
post #5
post #4

I really like the idea of Mastodon, but i can't shake this feeling that their name is kind of awful. I get that they're not trying to be exactly like twitter but by comparison, twitter is a much bubblier and friendlier word.

And the language of "toot" is extremely hokey and will never be taken seriously. It implies farting for most Americans. "Tweet" reminds people of birds. As in "a little bird told me". Which is appropriate for a gossip style network.

[deleted]

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A few people show up to say this every time Mastodon is mentioned. I disagree, it's memorable and I like it. Obviously the users don't mind either. Twitter sounded like a dumb name too, but they kept it and now nobody thinks twice about it. (Can you imagine: "Twit means idiot, nobody will use this service because of that!") Most creative names sound dumb until they stick around long enough.

Twitter = cute birds chirping at each other to communicate Mastodon = extinct elephant-like mammal This is why successful companies hire marketers.

Funny, the first thing I get when I think of a mastodon is fur, and that it's a huge animal. I guess it's all in the eye of the beholder... like most branding, TBH.

Having been in the room when working on branding, there's always plausible objections unless the brand is completely anodyne, and by extension terminally forgettable. At the end of the day you just have to go with something that isn't terrible.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Social communications software is all about the number of users. It needs to able to catch on everywhere. A term that sounds embarassing to many of its potential users is a real problem.

As a modestly funded project, Mastodon is never going to achieve "hockey stick" growth, and it would probably be overwhelmed if this happened. It's better for them to pursue a strategy of gradual, steady growth. Mastodon is continuing to grow steadily, and it does so in the face of established players who can outspend and outrun them. 2 million users is pretty damn good for an open source project that doesn't have a…

The terminology is still going to seriously hinder uptake. All of what you said can be true and better terminology would still be better for them.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#40
post #5
post #4

I really like the idea of Mastodon, but i can't shake this feeling that their name is kind of awful. I get that they're not trying to be exactly like twitter but by comparison, twitter is a much bubblier and friendlier word.

And the language of "toot" is extremely hokey and will never be taken seriously. It implies farting for most Americans. "Tweet" reminds people of birds. As in "a little bird told me". Which is appropriate for a gossip style network.

[Edit: people downvoting this, care to explain what you disagree with in it?]

Breaking news. In a series of explosive toots...

The foreign minister was forced to resign after a number of offensive toots...

OMG, your toots are so funny!...

Everyone's talking about what J K Rowling tooted today...

I can't believe you tooted that!...

...and so on

If you think I'm joking then that shows how bad a name "toot" is. Because these are all phrases that people would say about tweets, and which need to sound non-ridiculous for any such system.

Post reply on HN