Live data from Hacker News

Nanaimo bar gets Canada Post stamp, but critics question base-to-filling ratio

vancouversun.com

31–38 of 38 posts

Re: Nanaimo bar gets Canada Post stamp, but critics question base-to-filling ratio

#32
post #21

So I always thought that 'sugar pie' was a pet name for a loved one. Apparently not [1], I guess it is also a pet name, else there's a few songs I need to re evaluate. Ps Does North America not use the word tart. The wikipedia page describes it as a 'single-crust' pie? How do you differentiate those annoying upside down tart 'pies' consisting of a disc of pastry plonked on top? [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sug…

A tart is a pie with a bottom crust and no top crust. What you're describing as an upside-down tart is a grunt. If you bake a grunt but serve it upside down, it's a slump.

There are also betties, crumbles, crisps, buckles, clafoutis, cobblers, crisps and pandowdies. Each is different, and some have regional disagreements.

Re: Nanaimo bar gets Canada Post stamp, but critics question base-to-filling ratio

#36

Proving once again that the quickest way to success is to check with your customers. Rather than a secret build then a big reveal Canada Post could have checked in with some local experts for each dessert to ensure they had the best representation possible. Canada Post isn't a startup and they aren't looking for "market fit" but the same principles apply.

No, it really begs the question of "how many Canadians were involved in designing this stamp?"

Subject-matter experts are always required.

Re: Nanaimo bar gets Canada Post stamp, but critics question base-to-filling ratio

#37
post #32
post #21

So I always thought that 'sugar pie' was a pet name for a loved one. Apparently not [1], I guess it is also a pet name, else there's a few songs I need to re evaluate. Ps Does North America not use the word tart. The wikipedia page describes it as a 'single-crust' pie? How do you differentiate those annoying upside down tart 'pies' consisting of a disc of pastry plonked on top? [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sug…

A tart is a pie with a bottom crust and no top crust. What you're describing as an upside-down tart is a grunt. If you bake a grunt but serve it upside down, it's a slump. There are also betties, crumbles, crisps, buckles, clafoutis, cobblers, crisps and pandowdies. Each is different, and some have regional disagreements.

Wikipedia suggests that a grunt is a type of cobbler [1]? Although [2] suggests its steamed?

[2] also suggests a slump is yet another cobbler variation.

The upside down tarts are what they try to pass off as pies in British pubs, I wouldn't class them as pies, just like I wouldn't class a tart as a pie. British crumbles,cobblers et al don't tend to have pastry bottoms, so I wouldn't class those as pies either.

Shepherds, Cumberland and cottage pie...... Are the exception that proves the rule :)

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobbler_(food)

[2] https://www.seriouseats.com/2014/07/what-is-cobbler-crisp-cr...

Re: Nanaimo bar gets Canada Post stamp, but critics question base-to-filling ratio

#38
post #33

That looks a lot like a tompouce to me: https://www.google.com/search?q=tompouce&rlz=1C1GCEA_enNL749...

That's made with layers of pastry on the top and bottom, right? I believe that the Nanaimo bar has a biscuit base, like a cheesecake, and chocolate icing on top. The custard core is a common point, though.
Post reply on HN