Live data from Hacker News

First .dev Domains Go Live

blog.google

31–40 of 227 posts

Re: First .dev Domains Go Live

#31
post #12

I sort of get the appeal of a '.dev' TLD, but I wish that google donated the whole thing to those who were using it informally for local development. That would have been a good gift to all the devs out there.

There are more devs than just web devs. Just sayin'

Web devs aren't the only ones that need test/dummy hostnames. That being said, as mentioned in another comment, there are other TLDs already reserved for such use.

Re: First .dev Domains Go Live

#32
post #24

There is one thing that annoys me about generic TLDs like .dev, .website, .cloud, .network etc. For example, Salesforce have https://crm.dev - are they the only CRM in the world? Hell no, but they're the biggest, so they can be the only one in the .dev space. Same with workers.dev.

Some computer company gets to have apple.com, the car company does not have nissan.com, etc. etc.

I'm really glad the Nissan case went the way it did. It was the guy's family name after all, as well as a word in Hebrew.

Re: First .dev Domains Go Live

#33
post #26

On a recent thread Google personnel mentioned that ICANN forces all domain providers to backup their data so that any domain provider going bankrupt won't affect domains. However there was no mention of what procedures Google Domains themselves have put in place to protect their customers in case their customers get irreversibly banned somewhere within Google's vast empire. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=191787…

The domains customers aren't tied to Google user accounts. You buy them from the regular registrars like Gandi.net or (heaven forbid) Godaddy, and use them from your dashboards there. You don't have to use a gmail address anywhere.

If you buy them through Google Domains you need your Google account to renew domains, set nameservers etc, which is why these other registrars should be used.

This same argument actually dates back years for not using your web host for your domain registrar, because of contrived problems hindering domain transfers.

Re: First .dev Domains Go Live

#34
This landrush is different.

Try putting a one-character .dev domain in your cart (0.dev is available as of now). It's not a lump sum plus $12/year. It's thousands every year after registration.

In a way, I guess this is useful for deterring "domainers".

Even a 4-letter word or name .dev is hundreds of dollars a year. I wonder if the annual fee will drop as the days go by or just the purchase price.

Re: First .dev Domains Go Live

#35
post #18
post #12

I sort of get the appeal of a '.dev' TLD, but I wish that google donated the whole thing to those who were using it informally for local development. That would have been a good gift to all the devs out there.

The `.test` and `.localhost` TLDs are already reserved for such purposes: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2606

.test is OK, but as was pointed out in the HN discussion on this topic last week, .localhost is problematic in some operating systems.

Re: First .dev Domains Go Live

#37
Do TLDs even matter? I'm working on building a professional blog, and although a .dev TLD seems appropriate, using a cheaper one like .co or .be, or even .io seems functionally identical and a lot less costly. Paying hundreds or thousands for .dev seems like paying for pure vanity.

Is it going to help people reach your site? I kinda doubt it. Will Google use it to index your site differently? Maybe, but I dunno. I hope not, but it would kind of make sense.

Post reply on HN