Live data from Hacker News

Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

bbc.com

31–40 of 109 posts

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#31
post #13

Since maternity and paternity leave are frequently more than 6 months long, employees temporarily leaving for a big chunk of the year is just a fact of doing business here. Granting unpaid leave to go try your own thing for a while is, from the employer's perspective, not any different. Some people never come back, most people do. The same is true for parental leave (many quit their jobs towards the end of their leav…

I think the proper English word for this role is contractor rather than consultant.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#32
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>This is what a strong economy actually looks like. No mention of wages and jobs. In Electrical Engineering(US), its vicious the amount of competition trying to get me. Vacation policy? Unpaid, but at 60$/hr, I just afford to take 3 weeks of vacation, but 2 weeks of holidays too.

Congratulations on being in a high-demand field. It’s pretty great. But it’s definitely not the experience for most American workers.

Is the Swedish case the same even for non-high demand fields? I suppose by definition every job (irrespective of compensation or skill needed) would be a high demand field if it takes 12 months to fill; at which point I suggest that what Sweden has is a demographics problem, not a strong economy.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#33
post #27
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I first learned about this type of contract I couldn’t even believe the concept. How can anybody think it’s ok that a company can claim and kind of ownership over things an employee does in his free time? I have signed up for 40 hours a week and not for being fully owned by the company. What happens if you work another job and invent things there? Do the companies own each other’s stuff?

So would you assume you can work 40 hr and trade secrets from your employer as a side hustle, just because it's not happening within the work time?

You're presumably already bound to confidentiality.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#34
post #27
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When I first learned about this type of contract I couldn’t even believe the concept. How can anybody think it’s ok that a company can claim and kind of ownership over things an employee does in his free time? I have signed up for 40 hours a week and not for being fully owned by the company. What happens if you work another job and invent things there? Do the companies own each other’s stuff?

So would you assume you can work 40 hr and trade secrets from your employer as a side hustle, just because it's not happening within the work time?

This is not about trade secrets.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The fear is that otherwise you will quit. Hiring is hard here, so it's better to have a promise of someone coming back in 6 months than a job opening that can take 12 months to fill. This is what a strong economy actually looks like. It's hard (in my experience) to get Americans to understand this, because our economy here has been so bad for so long, most people here have never experienced anything like this.

>This is what a strong economy actually looks like. No mention of wages and jobs. In Electrical Engineering(US), its vicious the amount of competition trying to get me. Vacation policy? Unpaid, but at 60$/hr, I just afford to take 3 weeks of vacation, but 2 weeks of holidays too.

> In Electrical Engineering(US), its vicious the amount of competition trying to get me.

When did that start? I left EE in about 2006 because I felt like all the employers were very demanding of specific skillsets and treated engineers like they were easily replaceable.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#36
post #28
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So would you assume you can work 40 hr and trade secrets from your employer as a side hustle, just because it's not happening within the work time?

Are those contract clauses limited to trade secrets?

They often are not limited. In essence the company claims it owns all your creative output while you are employed.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#37
post #13

Since maternity and paternity leave are frequently more than 6 months long, employees temporarily leaving for a big chunk of the year is just a fact of doing business here. Granting unpaid leave to go try your own thing for a while is, from the employer's perspective, not any different. Some people never come back, most people do. The same is true for parental leave (many quit their jobs towards the end of their leav…

> The fear is that otherwise you will quit. Hiring is hard here, so it's better to have a promise of someone coming back in 6 months than a job opening that can take 12 months to fill. This is what a strong economy actually looks like. It's hard (in my experience) to get Americans to understand this, because our economy here has been so bad for so long, most people here have never experienced anything like this.

[dead]

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#38
post #2

I think this is brilliant, but I’m interested to hear criticisms or arguments against it.

Well, the biggest argument against it will be a need to find and train a temporary replacement for the person. For many positions finding and training alone may take longer than that. And then what do you do with the replacement once the original guy is back? Overall though, I would agree that benefits overweight potential problems.

I imagine the situation would be quite similar to how we handle maternity/paternity leave here in Canada, and it's rarely a problem.

Once its an accepted pattern, there are fewer surprises, and most people are understanding.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#39
post #3
post #2

I think this is brilliant, but I’m interested to hear criticisms or arguments against it.

Even assuming there's a de minimis exemption for small businesses, one unintended consequence could be increasing employment costs which would negatively effect business formation by disproportionately favoring established entities that could afford the luxury.

The article doesn't have details, really— but as the leave is unpaid I gather most of the costs would come in the form of any production delays or HR/admin. This makes me curious as to whether there are grants or subsidies from the government in support of the program.

Re: Sweden's leave of absence system helps workers launch their own business

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, the biggest argument against it will be a need to find and train a temporary replacement for the person. For many positions finding and training alone may take longer than that. And then what do you do with the replacement once the original guy is back? Overall though, I would agree that benefits overweight potential problems.

I imagine the situation would be quite similar to how we handle maternity/paternity leave here in Canada, and it's rarely a problem. Once its an accepted pattern, there are fewer surprises, and most people are understanding.

Exactly. It was briefly mentioned in the article too. Sweden already has a mature maternity/paternity system in place, and companies handle those just fine (in most cases, if they're doing any kind of planning and thinking). Thus they can handle these kinds of leaves as well - it's minor when you compare to the number of maternity/paternity leaves, there's much more of the latter. And (as it was mentioned in the article), it is possible to say 'no' to the leave if the employee's position is crucial (presumably there are definitions for what the actually means). Or hold it off for some time. Unlike with maternity/paternity leaves.

I wish there was something like this in my country as well.

Post reply on HN