Live data from Hacker News

Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

blog.chaddickerson.com

31–40 of 151 posts

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#31
My family does monthly email updates mainly because not everyone is on Facebook. No noise. Just what's new with everyone, once in a while. There's no ads, no posts about what they had for lunch, no reposts about their political opinions, etc.

We don't even use mailing lists. We usually just reply to the last one, and I have a contact group with everyone in the family.

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#32
Not sure how best to express this thought but it seems to my geriatric mind that some kind of p2p-ified (server+client in one) variation on NNTP could provide a "social network" with similar qualities to email but (unlike email), is something I pull from rather than gets pushed to me. Discoverability might be an issue though.

Is any of this making any sense?

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#33
post #11

> My email list is broadcast-only but any replies go directly to me. This sort of mass-email is weirdly impersonal because it tells the recipient that you want them to know what you're up to, but you don't want to write a message just to them. Also, it would be very awkward to opt-out ("hey dude, um please don't send me your mass-email updates anymore."), unlike company emails which there's no awkwardness around unsu…

> weirdly impersonal because it tells the recipient that you want them to know what you're up to, but you don't want to write a message just to them. Also, it would be very awkward to opt-out ("hey dude, um please don't send me your mass-email updates anymore.") You mean, like a post on FB ? Or Tweeting ? Readable for all ‘friends’ or ‘followers’ ? Who very likely are not really interested in your message ?

web forums (and properly managed email lists) have Unsubscribe options and Pull alternative to Push for consuming content.

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#34
For me, Facebook is still the only way to keep up with my closest friends and family. I live 3k+ miles away from were I grew up, and it's Facebook's asynchronous form of communication that allows me to spend minimal effort to keep abreast of what's going on there.

Another thing that Facebook offers is the ability to get to know who I'm dealing with when I friend a new colleague or someone I just started hanging out with. It's a great way to spark conversation "oh hey, I see you made cocktails last night, I love run rummers!". Or, "I see you liked Datsik, want to go to a concert with me?". That's essentially how I met my wife.

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#36

My wife's family keep a group message chat going indefinitely; it seems to work for them.

That only works if everyone in the group likes each other well enough, and the boundary of the group is agreed by consensus -- not most families :-)

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#37
post #24

> My email list is broadcast-only but any replies go directly to me. If I were to do this, I actually think it would be cool if those in the mailing list could choose whether they want to reply to the whole list or to just me (as easy as removing the list from the CC line). That way, there can be a semi-public discourse with your friends, if you still want something like the "comment thread" from facebook.

Have you ever worked at a company with reply-all spam?

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#38

My family does monthly email updates mainly because not everyone is on Facebook. No noise. Just what's new with everyone, once in a while. There's no ads, no posts about what they had for lunch, no reposts about their political opinions, etc. We don't even use mailing lists. We usually just reply to the last one, and I have a contact group with everyone in the family.

Who is "everyone" in your family? According to ancestry.com that's an absurdly large group.

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#39
Forget going email - I am thinking of going back to snail mail. I received a written card invitation in the mail yesterday from a good friend [0] inviting our family to a dinner, and it felt indescribably nice to get it and read it.

Something nice about holding it in your hands and reading it, then placing it on my desk somewhere so I could see it and be reminded of the good feelings every time I glanced at it.

[0] - https://twitter.com/dsabar/status/1085727043956830209

Re: Going old school: how I replaced Facebook with email

#40

Forget going email - I am thinking of going back to snail mail. I received a written card invitation in the mail yesterday from a good friend [0] inviting our family to a dinner, and it felt indescribably nice to get it and read it. Something nice about holding it in your hands and reading it, then placing it on my desk somewhere so I could see it and be reminded of the good feelings every time I glanced at it. [0] -…

I write letters to a friend in the U.S. from NZ at least once every 2 months. If you don't have stamps and envelopes handy it can be annoying at times but there's something about spending an hour reading, re-reading and then writing a personal letter by hand.

Also, once you write something, there's no backspace. You either re-write the page completely or leave a mess.

Post reply on HN