Live data from Hacker News

Recovery of Lost Indigenous Languages by Optical Scanning of Old Wax Cylinders

openculture.com

31–32 of 32 posts

Re: Recovery of Lost Indigenous Languages by Optical Scanning of Old Wax Cylinders

#31
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Paraphrases of what I've heard from Native American friends: My gift to you is this song. I cannot sing that song because it was not given to me. Intellectual property is apparently an ancient social construct!

It's not about intellectual property, it's an "it's the thought that counts" type of thing that is hard to explain to outsiders. In several cultures, singing someone a song is a very personal act of gift giving in which the singer creates beautiful sound just for the listener(s) - it is as much an expression of the relationship between them as it is about music or poetry. That latter bit is often lost in developed co…

That makes diary's purchased at an estate sale or a photo album interesting.

What is the law on that?

Re: Recovery of Lost Indigenous Languages by Optical Scanning of Old Wax Cylinders

#32
post #29
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I live in southeast Alaska, and it's a pretty interesting place to live culturally. Alaska Native people were hurt deeply by contact with outsiders. For those unfamiliar with the history, it was a series of events. First, contact brought diseases that native people had limited immunity to. Smallpox, influenza, and tuberculosis killed on the order of 70% of the population of many villages in a single generation. Then…

Is a romantic point of view but also a biased one. Yes, I agree that Native People were victims of diseases and suffered a lot of abuses. But would would be unfair not to mention that they received also some in exchange. They benefit of a new universe of human knowledge, around four thousand years of philosophy, technology and science and incredible advances on medicine and surgery that the native people couldn't eve…

We (the defendants of the white people who conquered this land) are the net losers, we lost several millennia of oral history and tribal knowledge.

In my opinion, we also lost something else, the idea that land is not something just to be owned and used, but rather something to be shepparded over, and held in trust for the next generations. It took us 200 years or so to rediscover that cultural precept.

Post reply on HN