Live data from Hacker News

See How Well Google Knows Your Circle of Friends

google.com

31–33 of 33 posts

Re: See How Well Google Knows Your Circle of Friends

#31
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some of it is from people I've exchanged emails with over GMail, which shouldn't be public data, unless Google has leaked it out somehow.

Did you see this: http://www.google.com/support/websearch/bin/answer.py?hl=en&... especially the bit about the difference between Public and Private connections?

I'm sorry my point is that I don't want to see private connection results myself in addition to no one else seeing them.

Re: See How Well Google Knows Your Circle of Friends

#32
post #28

Google is missing the thing that Facebook does well here, "identifying real people" . [0] When I looked at the "Friends" google identified it was really just connections I'd made with Twitter, flickr and various other services. Very few I'd met or consider a friend. Parsing data to find friends isn't as good as being sucked into the human "social graph" . Identifying real people is a core concept at Facebook. and som…

The title of this post probably mislead you, but identifying friends is just a subset of what Google is trying to do here. If I'm searching for a good online backup service I care more about the opinions of people I follow on twitter than those of my non-technical friends and family, etc.

Good point I hadn't considered the real purpose of the service. But one thing I can't understand is why google - the kings of simple - want to include such messy data? When I see "do more" I smell failure.

Re: See How Well Google Knows Your Circle of Friends

#33
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The title of this post probably mislead you, but identifying friends is just a subset of what Google is trying to do here. If I'm searching for a good online backup service I care more about the opinions of people I follow on twitter than those of my non-technical friends and family, etc.

Good point I hadn't considered the real purpose of the service. But one thing I can't understand is why google - the kings of simple - want to include such messy data? When I see "do more" I smell failure.

Google doesn't mind messy data at all. Their goal is to get more data, even if it's not perfect. If they can get massive amounts of data, their statistical accuracy will improve.
Post reply on HN