Live data from Hacker News

Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

techcrunch.com

31–40 of 81 posts

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#31
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can still use a passcode

The passcode doesn't let you get rid of the hideous screen cut-out, which seems to be primarily for this lock.

You would still need it for the normal front facing camera (look at the Essential Phone).

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#32

Why'd Apple choose to make the iPhone X out of stainless steel? Titanium, for example, would be half the weight and much more interesting..

Steel and aluminum is still cheaper and easier to work with than titanium. Easier manufacturing higher margins. P.S. the iphone is made of aluminum not steel

The edge of the X is made of "surgical-grade stainless steel"

https://www.apple.com/iphone-x/

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#34
post #28
post #2

This has not been well thought out for part of the world. https://www.pri.org/stories/2012-08-13/expand-job-opportunit...

What about twins? Does touch ID even work with twins?

No. They even brought up Spock and Evil Goatee Spock to mention that twins defeat it.

(I say "defeat". Schiller just said the chances of a false positive were higher with twins than the 1/1,000,000 base rate [compared with his claim of 1/50,000 for TouchID])

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#35
post #12

A non-conclusive list of places where this will be an issue: China, Japan, S.E.A.: Surgical masks against smog, or to avoid spreading germs. Northern Europe, Canada, Northern US: Winter clothing that covers the face to avoid the cold temperatures Middle East: Religious clothing for women hiding their faces. Anywhere with hot summers: Sunglasses covering the entire eyes, making it impossible to see if you’re looking a…

> Anywhere with hot summers: Sunglasses covering the entire eyes, making it impossible to see if you’re looking at the screen (which is a requirement for FaceID unlock).

I wonder if the IR sensor can actually see through the sunglasses?

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#36
post #28
post #2

This has not been well thought out for part of the world. https://www.pri.org/stories/2012-08-13/expand-job-opportunit...

What about twins? Does touch ID even work with twins?

This was explicitly brought up by the presenter (though through the premise of an "evil twin" and a photo of Spock from Mirror, Mirror) and they said you should consider a password.

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#37
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think steel is easier to manufacture and more abundant.

But it's supposed to be the no cost-cutting, ultra premium version of the iPhone. It costs a thousand dollars. They could've used titanium

Maybe saving it for the iPhone X2. It could also have pre drilled holes for setting gemstones.

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Steel and aluminum is still cheaper and easier to work with than titanium. Easier manufacturing higher margins. P.S. the iphone is made of aluminum not steel

The edge of the X is made of "surgical-grade stainless steel" https://www.apple.com/iphone-x/

If that's the case I stand corrected.

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#39

Why'd Apple choose to make the iPhone X out of stainless steel? Titanium, for example, would be half the weight and much more interesting..

Which material is less resistant to scratching? When I saw that shiny edge, I couldn't help but wonder how long it would take to get scuffed up.

Titanium is pretty soft so it would probably be more prone to scratching.

Re: Face ID is replacing Touch ID on the new iPhone X

#40
post #12

A non-conclusive list of places where this will be an issue: China, Japan, S.E.A.: Surgical masks against smog, or to avoid spreading germs. Northern Europe, Canada, Northern US: Winter clothing that covers the face to avoid the cold temperatures Middle East: Religious clothing for women hiding their faces. Anywhere with hot summers: Sunglasses covering the entire eyes, making it impossible to see if you’re looking a…

So, basically it works only in Northern California.
Post reply on HN