This is textbook PR, literally from the first word. The headline is crafted specifically to engender resentment and outrage. The intention is to reinforce the counterfactual narrative that teachers in the US are overpaid, which is needed to depress opposition to the looting of public school systems. Now, a market for lesson plans is interesting - and I'm much happier with money going to entrepreneurial teachers actua…
Could you point me to what you mean, or how you found that meaning here? I grant that I probably bring my own biases to this interpretation, but the article made me think, "teachers now have to spend their own salaries on teaching material because districts only buy lousy, overpriced stuff (if that) from textbook publishers. Worse yet, the jerks feel the need to attack the teachers who are sharing their material, as…
Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
31–38 of 38 posts
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#32I'll be curmudgeonly ... can someone open-source lesson plans so the community could work to improve them and they would be free? Teachers shouldn't have to be paying out of pocket for this stuff. Or does such a thing exist? I guess I'm torn: I like that teachers are seeing compensation by selling their lesson plans, hate that other teachers have to pay. (I'm personally working on a site to eventually provide free pr…
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#33I don't see the downside here. Being able to sell lesson plans would be a nice little bonus to often underpaid teachers. It would have the upside of having teachers put in a little more work in developing their lesson plans if they think they can sell them. Other teachers would be able to benefit greatly from purchasing other lesson plans and saving time and effort. I don't think it would harm the "traditional collab…
>I don't see the downside here. The new thing here isn't lesson plans for sale, it's a marketplace with small vendors. So this isn't a new downside, but sponsored content is a continual worry. A train carrying delicious Pepsi products is traveling from the Pepsi plant in Pepsi-town to the Pepsi distribution center in Pepsi-city. What is your favorite beverage?
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#34Man, I don't get why Teachers stress so much on lesson plans. I was a high school teacher for about a decade and after the first three years, it doesn't take long or difficult to have lesson plans available. If you want ideas, the school district often has a crap load of them. And if you are teaching a standardized course (like Algebra or Geometry) you are essentially provided lesson plans for every day. The website…
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#35Man, I don't get why Teachers stress so much on lesson plans. I was a high school teacher for about a decade and after the first three years, it doesn't take long or difficult to have lesson plans available. If you want ideas, the school district often has a crap load of them. And if you are teaching a standardized course (like Algebra or Geometry) you are essentially provided lesson plans for every day. The website…
> Owner/ Founder: Making-The-Grade Private Learning (Private Tutoring Services).
Your belief that there is nothing more to teaching than a lesson plan - "you could freely pick and choose from anyone in your district" - doesn't inspire confidence in the services you offer.
You also note that you're a Wordpress (sic) contractor. WordPress (note the capitalized P) is open source. Do you also believe that you could freely pick and choose from anyone (i.e. anybody without prior training or experience) to do WordPress development?
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#36Earlier quoted context omitted.
Could you point me to what you mean, or how you found that meaning here? I grant that I probably bring my own biases to this interpretation, but the article made me think, "teachers now have to spend their own salaries on teaching material because districts only buy lousy, overpriced stuff (if that) from textbook publishers. Worse yet, the jerks feel the need to attack the teachers who are sharing their material, as…
Starting off with the title of "Millionaire" would definitely annoy people.
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#37Earlier quoted context omitted.
Ideally we'd abandon this weird psuedo-capitalist idea of education and just convince our government that education is the best investment a country can make . An educated populace will devise better defense technologies and strategies. An educated populace will create more efficient means of production. An educated populace will strategize better trade deals. An educated populace will create more cultural icons that…
Throwing money at the problem isn't necessarily going to help. Tons of poor school districts have gotten major cash infusions and produced nothing to show for it. The money needs to be spent efficiently. Power needs to be taken away from administrators and given back to teachers. Also, bad teachers need to be fired.
Giving a million dollars to a homeless drug addict would kill him within the week. You don't solve the problem by throwing money at it, now.
I said increase the education budget. That's not just money to schools, that's money to education research, schools, teachers, after school programs, parent outreach, and all the other weird little things people don't think about when they think about education. It would shift our country's cultural and political policy towards education - if teachers are pulling 120k salaries, the expectations for their performance would be higher. More people would seek out the extra difficult training to become a teacher because the rewards are worth it, much like people are willing to spend 10 years slaving through medical school for a prominent, well-respected, highly paid job that involves helping people.
Right now the only people that teach are the genuinely good people that are willing to take 24k/year salaries minus personal expenses on classroom supplies, or yea, the shitty people who couldn't figure out what else to do.
Re: Millionaire teachers: a lucrative online marketplace for lesson plans
#38Man, I don't get why Teachers stress so much on lesson plans. I was a high school teacher for about a decade and after the first three years, it doesn't take long or difficult to have lesson plans available. If you want ideas, the school district often has a crap load of them. And if you are teaching a standardized course (like Algebra or Geometry) you are essentially provided lesson plans for every day. The website…
Your profile notes: > Owner/ Founder: Making-The-Grade Private Learning (Private Tutoring Services). Your belief that there is nothing more to teaching than a lesson plan - "you could freely pick and choose from anyone in your district" - doesn't inspire confidence in the services you offer. You also note that you're a Wordpress (sic) contractor. WordPress (note the capitalized P) is open source. Do you also believe…
I have been an educator for over a decade, and lesson plans are very low on the list of what makes someone a good or great teacher/educator.
Teaching successfully is a lot of things, but for me it is a presentation. Making an interesting presentation and guiding students through a course correctly is the true skill.
Lesson plans are mostly about inserting industry language and cool sounding bullet points into pdfs so that your administrator will be impressed. They are really useful to inexperienced teachers, but are largely an after thought for many great experienced teachers. When you open source them to people in your district, it would be easy for other teachers to get ideas from them and allow them to actually be useful for even the most experienced teachers.
You clearly didn't understand my comment, so please enlighten me on what your theory of teaching and education is and the role that lesson plans play in all of it.
Your question, which was probably rhetorical, about Wordpress (note the uncapitalized p) doesn't make any sense. If you want an honest debate, rephrase it.