Live data from Hacker News

A new home for Google Open Source

opensource.google.com

31–40 of 71 posts

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#31
post #8

2 years max.

The last one was like 10 years, so ... probably not?

This one seems to have the purpose of showing off google open source contributions (for marketing purposes?) rather than actually hosting. So the utility is much lower and the effort to maintain it is lower. I wouldn't expect many to miss it greatly if it disappeared one day since the actual contributions are elsewhere. I'm not sure how that translates into the expected lifetime for google keeping it around.

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#32
post #12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It just looks like a one-stop shop to increase discoverability of all of google's opensource project, including the ones not hosted on github, like ganeti[1]. Which is hosted on Google's own infra[2] [1]: https://opensource.google.com/projects/ganeti [2]: http://git.ganeti.org/?p=ganeti.git;a=summary

Except that the UI is so bad that you can only discover a few top ranked (whatever it means in this UI) projects or the project you already know it exists in there.

We recently thought about on how to do this as well and created our own Open Source page [1]. Not sure if we have done it right, but I quite like it. Happy to receive some feedback on it. It's nothing huge, nevertheless we're quite proud of what we've achieved.

[1]: https://mobilejazz.com/products/opensource

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#33
post #32
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except that the UI is so bad that you can only discover a few top ranked (whatever it means in this UI) projects or the project you already know it exists in there.

We recently thought about on how to do this as well and created our own Open Source page [1]. Not sure if we have done it right, but I quite like it. Happy to receive some feedback on it. It's nothing huge, nevertheless we're quite proud of what we've achieved. [1]: https://mobilejazz.com/products/opensource

This is nice, I like what you've done with the logos

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#34
post #12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It just looks like a one-stop shop to increase discoverability of all of google's opensource project, including the ones not hosted on github, like ganeti[1]. Which is hosted on Google's own infra[2] [1]: https://opensource.google.com/projects/ganeti [2]: http://git.ganeti.org/?p=ganeti.git;a=summary

Except that the UI is so bad that you can only discover a few top ranked (whatever it means in this UI) projects or the project you already know it exists in there.

There is an option make into a normal list its on the upper right hand side.

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#35
post #12
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It just looks like a one-stop shop to increase discoverability of all of google's opensource project, including the ones not hosted on github, like ganeti[1]. Which is hosted on Google's own infra[2] [1]: https://opensource.google.com/projects/ganeti [2]: http://git.ganeti.org/?p=ganeti.git;a=summary

Except that the UI is so bad that you can only discover a few top ranked (whatever it means in this UI) projects or the project you already know it exists in there.

Agree. Over use of animation. All these are good examples.

If Google has 50+ projects, then it's best to just have a page with multiple rows, each row is a category, and upon click can expand down to what #3 looks like. Or perhaps just GitHub README... it's pretty nice to read.

[1]: https://netflix.github.io/ [2]: http://twitter.github.io/ [3]: http://etsy.github.io/

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#36
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is not one bit surprising considering that Google does everything online. Google no doubt has some proprietary code that they would like to keep proprietary. Also they probably have code under other licenses that they would like to remain under those particular licenses.

Errr,it's completely and totally unrelated to that. It's because we have tons of temps, vendors, and contractors, and don't want to have to owe them source code to internal systems. The other alternative (remember that google is a monorepo) would be to somehow police them differently. That is literally not worth the cost.

I don't see how having "some proprietary code that they would like to keep proprietary" is "completely and totally unrelated to" "not want[ing] to have to owe [someone/anyone] source code to internal systems"?

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think parent is referring to the longevity of this "new home", given Google's tendency to cancel things.

I don't think anyone in this thread has actually opened the link. This "new home" isn't some sort of platform like Google Code, it's just a website that lists all of Google's open source projects (mainly on GitHub). Everyone's talking about it like it's supposed to be some sort of GitHub competitor that can be 'abandoned'.

I don't see why you feel like this website is something that Google can't abandon. Hell: I swear I remember Google already having a page like this six or seven years ago... I'd imagine this page will slowly become less and less maintained, with both layout rot and failing to include some new projects, until it eventually gets scrapped or replaced (with a new URL, and likely no redirect).

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think parent is referring to the longevity of this "new home", given Google's tendency to cancel things.

I don't think anyone in this thread has actually opened the link. This "new home" isn't some sort of platform like Google Code, it's just a website that lists all of Google's open source projects (mainly on GitHub). Everyone's talking about it like it's supposed to be some sort of GitHub competitor that can be 'abandoned'.

What they are saying is that eventually this site will be removed because Google is constantly killing their own projects after a couple of years.

Re: A new home for Google Open Source

#40
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except that the UI is so bad that you can only discover a few top ranked (whatever it means in this UI) projects or the project you already know it exists in there.

Well, all of it only really helps you discover the featured ones, because the list was opt in. The total number is in the thousands.

I routinely click through the google and gcp orgs, and I hadn't seen quite a few of these, a couple of which I'd really like to use. Congrats!
Post reply on HN