Live data from Hacker News

Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

nejm.org

31–40 of 88 posts

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#31
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You pay for private insurance or you pay for public insurance via taxes. Any other solution is unworkable and you are a free rider.

i'd like the choice to not have any insurance

That's not a sustainable choice for our economy, it leads to too many people living like nothing could possibly go wrong until they need a doctor. The point of insurance is to distribute risk, not participating in that effectively negates the effectiveness of the industry.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#32
post #9

I doubt anyone in Congress or the White House working to repeal the ACA reads the New England Journal of Medicine.

It's a pretty prestigious journal. It's likely that aides to senators and representatives in key positions, as well as it being forwarded from interested constituents will make sure that the article makes the rounds. And it's generally good political practice to keep informed on the moves made by major players. Likely people in the White House know about it as well.

When I say "read" I mean take the time to understand it and put thoughtful consideration into it. Repealing Obamacare is an idealogical imperative to most Republican legislators, it's intrinsic to their identity now. Awareness of what they probably consider propaganda is not the same as "reading" it.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#33
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You pay for private insurance or you pay for public insurance via taxes. Any other solution is unworkable and you are a free rider.

i'd like the choice to not have any insurance

You have that choice right now.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#34
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Choosing to not be insured is unsustainable for our economy the moment you have an issue and need a doctor.

so i shouldnt have the right to choose?

You've now made this same point three times in this thread without expanding your argument. Please make each comment each add substantively to the discussion.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#35
For 8 years, this man had the option to walk humanity back from the threat of hair-trigger, launch-on-warning nuclear armageddon. An armageddon that would either destroy humanity in a single day...or perhaps merely starve a few billion in the resulting nuclear winter. From these facts alone, I know everything I need to know about his, and all US presidents, commitment to the health of their citizens, and humanity at large.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#37

It's a wonderful idea. Free healthcare for all. Sadly, it simply isn't sustainable financially. I think in the next 10 years alone it was supposed to cost tax payers 10 trillion and that money can't literally be printed fast enough and the debt our country holds, extremely unsustainable. If they did it cheaper or more cost effective, I would say yes, but financially, you can't.

Do you mean the $10 trillion cost from repealing? Here is republican senator Rand Paul on the huge budgetary expense of ACA repeal https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6AuIwR00T5g

Still in disbelief that Rand Paul did not win the Republican primary.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#38
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Choosing to not be insured is unsustainable for our economy the moment you have an issue and need a doctor.

so i shouldnt have the right to choose?

No, because at some point you will inevitable need care. We build care systems in place and pay into them to mitigate and distribute risk. You are effectively free-riding on everyone else's participation.

Re: Barack Obama Publishes Defense of the ACA in the New England Journal of Medicine

#40

I doubt anyone in Congress or the White House working to repeal the ACA reads the New England Journal of Medicine.

They might not, but they are probably lobbied by doctors, hospital administrators, and insurance executives, all of whom are likely to at least skim the top medical journals.

I don't think any of these groups care much about affordable Care.
Post reply on HN