Live data from Hacker News

Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

wired.com

31–40 of 217 posts

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#31
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Obama is not going to be able to fill any spot that requires Senate confirmation.

I'm not sure it requires confirmation if it's filling a spot with an incomplete term.

If congress is in session it'd require confirmation. The exception is a recess appointment but that's not going to happen as they're already keeping congress continuously open to block Garland's recess appointment.

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#32
I was recently at a conference in DC called "Transforming Communities: Broadband Goals for 2017 and Beyond" which was largely focused on public policy related to the lack of real broadband in America. Gigi Sohn, who is the counselor to the chairman of the FCC, spoke.

She was very candid about the position of the FCC and the fact that she was finally able to speak her mind because this was going to be one of her last public appearances as a government official. One thing that stuck me was what she said about Tom[1]: "He actually believes that the consumer, the american people, are his clients. He's said that from the first day and he'll say that the day he leaves. Trust me, he doesn't like any of the companies [laughter]". The loss of the current administration of the FCC (including but not limited to Tom) will be a great loss for the American people in my opinion.

The conference was interesting and somewhat sad, because it was planned before the election and probably with the assumption that the new administration would not be totally hostile. Instead of the original direction of "here's what we've done and how we plan to carry these goals forward" it ended up being more of a retrospective on progress that had been made at the federal level that was about to be erased.

From the people I saw, there did not seem to be anyone there representing the new administration.

[1] https://youtu.be/O5drVTSpH5g?list=LLDlLvM2YAVFtSXvebIrlE0A&t...

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#33
post #10

Wait, he's the cable industry shill, right? So this is the best news ever?

He was the opposite in the recent times. Unlike any of his predecessors, he pushed a tremendous amount of consumer friendly policies and curbed monopolistic abuses of incumbents. He failed to repeal anti-competitive local state laws which ban municipal Internet, but he managed to pass Net Neutrality rules. It would be a pity if all that effort will be dismantled by corrupted commissioners backed by monopolists who ha…

He's being snarky. (I don't mind the downvotes, but: he really is. Ted doesn't think Wheeler is a cable industry shill. He's trying to make fun of people who do.)

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#34
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure it requires confirmation if it's filling a spot with an incomplete term.

If congress is in session it'd require confirmation. The exception is a recess appointment but that's not going to happen as they're already keeping congress continuously open to block Garland's recess appointment.

I thought they were going to enter recess to allow them to invoke a law that allows repealing decisions made by the executive within the last 60 days of sessions of Congress. Maybe I misunderstood an article on this?

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#35
post #28
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This type of thing has been said for years. I placed a long bet with a friend 7 years ago when he said "in 5 years" we'll have what was described above. Hasn't happened. Won't happen.

There's a reason it hasn't happened yet; it's not some sort of deterministic process. Many people worked hard to stop it from happening, and a new FCC chairman could change the status quo.

As another example of a self-defeating prophecy, consider Y2K. There was no major disaster because thousands of people worked incredibly hard to make sure there was no disaster.

Sometimes working in technology feels like working stage crew -- the audience doesn't give a crap about your existence until you screw up.

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#36
One of the problems with Net Neutrality is that techies (us) and the media have both had a hard time explaining it clearly.

Meanwhile those opposed have been able to come up with analogies that while false and misleading, are easily understood.

What is the best way to explain the concept that can be quickly understood by those that are non-technical?

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#37
post #23

Got an error when clicking on that link: "Wired.com is not included in your Comcast Internet Basic package. Click here to upgrade to Comcast Internet Extreme for $9.99 more a month, for access to Wired.com and twenty other premium web sites!"

This type of thing has been said for years. I placed a long bet with a friend 7 years ago when he said "in 5 years" we'll have what was described above. Hasn't happened. Won't happen.

Only because they figured out that it's more profitable to charge the other side, and that has happened, for example, Comcast getting Netflix to pay them to not throttle their traffic.

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#38

Wait, he's the cable industry shill, right? So this is the best news ever?

I've covered a lot of Tom Wheeler's work in the last few years. He's probably the best FCC head in the past two decades. If he had a rep previously for being an industry shill, he blew it out of the water in his three years at the helm. (Meanwhile, Michael Powell made the opposite move: He's currently in charge of the cable industry group.)

[deleted]

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#39
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure it requires confirmation if it's filling a spot with an incomplete term.

If congress is in session it'd require confirmation. The exception is a recess appointment but that's not going to happen as they're already keeping congress continuously open to block Garland's recess appointment.

That trick of procedurally gavelling open a session and immediately closing it to avoid the recess disgusts me beyond words. The GOP basically opted to treat the Constitution as a dead letter through tricks such as these and refusing to even dignify Garland's nomination with a hearing. Besides the political ramifications I think it's sad that a guy who's widely regarded as a decent hardworking jurist will have his legal career remembered only as a political football.

Re: Tom Wheeler Resigns from the FCC

#40
post #36

One of the problems with Net Neutrality is that techies (us) and the media have both had a hard time explaining it clearly. Meanwhile those opposed have been able to come up with analogies that while false and misleading, are easily understood. What is the best way to explain the concept that can be quickly understood by those that are non-technical?

"Imagine if your electricity company could decide that you pay more for some appliances than others."
Post reply on HN