Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 54 posts

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#31
One thing about Project Management that had always struck me why is this space so fragmented and why there is no clear winner? You can create a project management tool now with a new perspective and I am sure you will have customers for it.

My hunch suggests that there will be soon a Project Management tool that has growth trajectory similar to "Slack" or who knows it might be "Slack" itself.

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#32
I feel your pain. A few weeks ago I was even asked to track my time in a clients system. First thought was "but I send you invoices with my time in them."

Second thought was, "why don't you pay your staff to enter time from my invoices?"

Third thought was "I'll have to bill you a stupid hourly rate to enter my time in your system."

Right now I'm stuck at the third thought and they've agreed, but I haven't started doing it yet and don't want to. Their systems are their systems and mine are mine.

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#33
post #3

We actually ran into the exact same problem while juggling multiple projects and ended up creating Taco - https://tacoapp.com . Taco aggregates your Basecamp, Trello, Asana and 35+ other services into a single screen so you can prioritize your day across multiple services. Works especially well with a new tab Chrome extension. Haven't found the best way to consolidate applications for real time services. Although, I'…

Put a slack bot interface in front of this and I will love you forever.

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#34
post #28

Don't treat your customers' project management systems as your own organization tools. Instead, treat them as deliverables and manage your own organization elsewhere.

Good point. I do use Trello for all my internal stuff, then checklists inside my cards for each project. But then I find I forget to update my checklists in my Clients' project management tools :( I guess that's just a personal problem I need to figure out though. EDIT 2: Updated the wrong comment.

When I have that situation, I use IFTTT to auto-create a Trello card to update their stuff on whatever day.

It's not elegant but it means that I can use the tools that are the most relevant and ignore everything else in the meantime.

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#35
post #3

We actually ran into the exact same problem while juggling multiple projects and ended up creating Taco - https://tacoapp.com . Taco aggregates your Basecamp, Trello, Asana and 35+ other services into a single screen so you can prioritize your day across multiple services. Works especially well with a new tab Chrome extension. Haven't found the best way to consolidate applications for real time services. Although, I'…

Trying it out myself. One suggestion for your Chrome App - don't ask for permission to gibberishasdfasdf.cloudfront.com - that stuff is easy to whitelabel. Permissions scare users, especially when there is gibberish.

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#36
post #3

We actually ran into the exact same problem while juggling multiple projects and ended up creating Taco - https://tacoapp.com . Taco aggregates your Basecamp, Trello, Asana and 35+ other services into a single screen so you can prioritize your day across multiple services. Works especially well with a new tab Chrome extension. Haven't found the best way to consolidate applications for real time services. Although, I'…

Put a slack bot interface in front of this and I will love you forever.

Actually, we are in the works of releasing a Slack connector. Star a message or DM in Slack and see it as a task in Taco. Taco only asks for and obtains access to your starred messages (on https://api.slack.com/docs/oauth-scopes, "stars:list" and "stars:remove"), not all archives. Shoot us an email at support@tacoapp.com if you'd like to help us test it out!

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've found the same applies to corporate organization tools. I manage my tasks separately with "update JIRA" being one of those tasks.

I hope you at least leave notes about what you do. Few things are more infuriating than seeing a complex task assigned to someone, and the next entry is "Solved." and the ticket closed. Great that the problem was solved, but the corporate organization tool exists to make solution information more available to others with the same problem. In a way, ticket systems are another type of documentation, along with man page…

Well he does, in his own systems. Not in yours. Is my guess.

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#38
Juggling systems is goofy but as long as they're web based it's easy, go old school

+customer data folder ++customer name > links to trello,slack go here +++project name > links to trello etc. go here

then I have a todo.md or todo.txt using imdone-atom with snippits, gives you a text based kanban, you can open project folders with atom --add c:\customers\abc\project1 and alt-t for tasks

also alt-j is journal where you can try to kanban all customers if you're ocd

documentation should not go in a ticket system, it should go in a wiki

my fav is a combo of integrated apps like trello/slack, jira/confluence, github/gitter

tasks are todo/doing/done and done includes closing their ticket system and updating their wiki or whatever they're using like a wiki

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hope you at least leave notes about what you do. Few things are more infuriating than seeing a complex task assigned to someone, and the next entry is "Solved." and the ticket closed. Great that the problem was solved, but the corporate organization tool exists to make solution information more available to others with the same problem. In a way, ticket systems are another type of documentation, along with man page…

Well he does, in his own systems. Not in yours. Is my guess.

Sure, though adding in note is a kind of signaling -- a social mechanism that helps teams come together. If someone is working as a contractor, is relatively isolated from the team, then there probably won't be a need or even a desire for the contractor to add notes to the client's management system, for the sake of signaling to the in-house development team. On the other hand, some sort of notes tend to make many non-technical clients feel better and be on top of things. (And some people are confused by signaling; a good communicator would be able to suss that out).

Re: Ask HN: How do you deal with so many project management systems?

#40
I'm curious whether big companies like Google or Facebook have a standard project management process or software used by all teams. I work at Mozilla and every team is doing their own thing, which can make collaboration difficult. We have Bugzilla bugs, GitHub issues, wikis, Mana (Confluence's wiki), Google Docs and spreadsheets, Trello, Smartsheets, Aha, and JIRA. Even when people agree there is a problem, no team wants to be the one to change their process.. :)
Post reply on HN