Live data from Hacker News

DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

deepexcel.net

31–35 of 35 posts

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#31
post #16

I laughed because it was funny. Then I laughed again harder when I realized that it was supposed to be funny.

The first table in the whitepaper - "Commie open source license" ... excellent

"Commie" was a strong enough hint, which make me read the whole thing again in a different light.

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#32
For those who don't know: this is a satirical post.

It's kind of funny, I guess.

But I didn't assume it was a farce. I was genuinely excited to see the implementation, because there is something unique about the transparency and interaction you can have with an excel workbook. It's almost like a GUI for a lisp REPL. Even if I am too dumb to understand the actual c code, I can see the relevant numbers being crunched, how they relate, and more.

So... "good one. you got me."

But even as I sit here as the butt of the joke, I find myself wishing your link had been sincere.

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#34

Oh boy. I'm the second author. The official announcement will be in April 1st at the SIGBOVIK conference ( http://sigbovik.org/2016 ), but I guess someone broke the press embargo! By the way: It works, try it ;)

Can't wait to see the paper clip fella suggest informative features—maybe? :)

Re: DeepExcel – Deep learning in Excel

#35
post #2

Don't want to be an asshole but it really can't be called Deep Learning if it doesn't do backprob. Deep inference, at best. The paper reads like a bad joke.

Backprop may be added in the future. Meanwhile you can just adjust the weights directly! (They're in the "layer*" sheets).

Back propagation just slows things down.
Post reply on HN