Live data from Hacker News

What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

quizlet.com

31–40 of 136 posts

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#31
I don't agree with the OP ; however GCP's sub-hour billing is nice. I need to process a lot of tasks that take longer that 5 minutes which makes them unsuitable for AWS Lambda. With GCP , I only end up paying for a maximum of 10 ~15 minutes-- which is a nice cost saving. Dear AWS -- if you are reading this, match this and I will never ever leave you, not even for 10 minutes.

edit : typo

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#32

My main concern with picking GCP would be that Google has a history of shutting down projects. I feel like they are more likely to shutter GCP than Amazon is with AWS.

I think if they demonstrate that they dogfood it the way Amazon does it will go a long way. Based on talks I've seen I know some internal teams use it (or at least did when it was free for them).

they also used google reader for gmail (it was integrated on the top of the inbox). it didn't stop them from killing it.

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#33

My main concern with picking GCP would be that Google has a history of shutting down projects. I feel like they are more likely to shutter GCP than Amazon is with AWS.

``Google Cloud CTO Urs Hölzle has said publicly that `One day, this could be bigger than ads. Certainly, in terms of market potential, it is.' Diane Greene now leads the division that includes GCP---from our perspective it’s nice to know that the cloud division has a seat on the Google Board of Directors.''

It seems that if Google believes in GCP being almost as big as AdWords, the likelihood of GCP Compute being shut down is as likely as GMail for Business being shut down. Not saying that it couldn't happen, but with Spotify and Quizlet using GCP instances, I find it highly unlikely the compute platform would go away, especially with paying users. A free product on the other hand could die on a whim.

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#34

This should really be titled "A comparison of AWS and GCP." It totally wrote off Azure (2nd in market size) because its a "Linux second" cloud (what does that even mean in a virtualized world). Also, you forgot to analyze support and SLAs around functionality. Good luck with GCP when something goes wrong or they decide to sunset a feature.

Support is much better on GCP than AWS. Reference: https://news.spotify.com/us/2016/02/23/announcing-spotify-in... One of the reasons why Spotify went with Google Cloud is because of their superior support.

Spotify is one datapoint, and I hate to be cynical, but was probably paid off (in free / drastically reduced priced cloud services ala Netflix on AWS) by Google to write all of that.

Even if not, they are such a large well known name that they probably got special treatment. The real proof in the pudding is the support that the 99% get, not the special case 1%.

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#36
post #5

The Best Cloud is probably a combination of all. Since that would give you the highest Availability.

I actually know of some companies that run part of their infrastructure on AWS and part on GCP.

There are companies that help you run "seamlessly" on any cloud provider you want so in theory you can use them to balance your services between cloud provider for cost or performance.

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#37
I wonder why Quizlet didn't just stick with Joyent but switch from SmartOS to the newer Linux-based infrastructure containers and/or Docker containers. Joyent put a lot of effort into reviving LX-branded zones on Illumos precisely to address the concern that this article raises with using an OS other than Linux.

Also, why dismiss DigitalOcean as a niche provider for hobbyists? The simple pricing, with lots of data transfer included, should appeal to a lot of businesses too.

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#38

My main concern with picking GCP would be that Google has a history of shutting down projects. I feel like they are more likely to shutter GCP than Amazon is with AWS.

http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/10/30/amazon-shutting-dow...

http://www.cpcstrategy.com/blog/2015/08/amazon-product-ads-d...

http://www.cpcstrategy.com/blog/2015/10/amazon-text-ads-disc...

http://www.cnbc.com/2015/09/09/amazon-discontinues-disappoin...

http://uk.businessinsider.com/amazon-discontinues-amazon-ele... :)

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#39

"Azure was eliminated since its a Linux-second cloud" I have a feeling this person never really dove into Azure, and just wrote it off because it had Microsoft services built in; and of course various sysadmins still have a strong bias against Microsoft, especially if they are Open Source advocates. Seems like the entire article is mostly just comparing AWS to GCP instead of giving an actual overview of the cloud lan…

Honest question. If you are a 100% linux shop, what do you gain with Azure? Do they have better linux chops than GCE or AWS?

Re: What's the Best Cloud? Probably GCP

#40

Interesting read. Can someone explain this point to me? "Software-defined networking means that google.com appears to be one hop away" One hop from...? Everywhere? Each server? How does that help? I understand 'traceroute' but not where that single hop to Google comes in and why that's great.

Sure - this isn't really a dimension of comparison, just something that I found interesting / surprising. It seems like SDN is probably the future, and this is an illustration of how its different.
Post reply on HN