Live data from Hacker News

Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

cvilletomorrow.org

31–40 of 138 posts

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#31
I'll copy a very interesting comment by Anton Largiader http://www.cvilletomorrow.org/news/article/22908-locust-aven...

> One very interesting approach I have seen overseas is a traffic light that turns red if you are speeding as you approach it. It's incredibly effective; instant feedback on your behavior, and immediate loss of any time you gained by speeding. No ticket, unless you run the light. Drivers quickly conclude they're better off by not speeding.

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#32

I think an even better application of this technology would be to catch people who aren't stopping at signs/lights, or not yielding at merges. Radar-equipped signs can handle the speeding case fairly well, but are useless in these other - and often more dangerous - cases.

Yes! If not to catch violators, at least to collect data for use in enforcement. In cities and towns with lots of pedestrians, the stop sign case is key. People check for other cars by habit, but often overlook pedestrians waiting to cross at a stop sign and put them at risk.

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#33

A pretty common sight around here (western europe) which seems to work pretty well are dynamic reminder signs: electronic signposts with a speed radar, which simply displays your speed in green if you're under the limit, orange if you're a bit over and blinking red if you're way over (using fairly bright led arrays so it's visible in most conditions) Anecdotally, it seems to work pretty well, drivers do slow down whe…

The article shows evidence for the contrary, the city actually installed such a sign. It slowed motorists for a while, but they eventually sped back up again.

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#34

I wonder how the HN commentariat would feel about this if it was a government agency behind this rather than a fellow hacker...

The major question for me would be data retention – if they monitor speed (or failing to stop at a red light or stop sign, etc.) but fundamentally aren't doing anything different than if they parked an officer there with a radar gun, it doesn't bother me.

Saving the data for later mining, OCRing license plates to build a record of cars traveling around town, etc. would be a different story because that affects everyone whether or not they're choosing to break the law and spans more than a single incident in time.

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#36

This is gross, and reminds me of the nosy old ladies that 'patrol' the neighbourhood around here, only this guy knows C.

Or the retiree condo commanders going around measuring people's shrubs to make sure they comply with condo bylaws section 4, subsection 65, paragraph 5. For some people, ubiquitous rule enforcement is a utopia, not a Orwellian nightmare.

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#37
post #20
post #6

> At 4:27 p.m. last Wednesday, the system caught a Route 11 city bus doing 34 mph. Which isn't even fast enough to get a ticket from local police. In my state (which is not Virginia, and it will vary everywhere), local police are prohibited from using radar and need to use an actual stopwatch to track your speed. Obviously very error prone, and they're supposed to basically give you 10 mph leeway - meaning on that ro…

I live in Va, just not that part, and the rule of thumb is anything less then 10mph over and you generally won't get a ticket. The only exception to this is places like school zones.

Unless you're on 495 then it's like 20mph over and the police may still pass you....

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#38
post #6

> At 4:27 p.m. last Wednesday, the system caught a Route 11 city bus doing 34 mph. Which isn't even fast enough to get a ticket from local police. In my state (which is not Virginia, and it will vary everywhere), local police are prohibited from using radar and need to use an actual stopwatch to track your speed. Obviously very error prone, and they're supposed to basically give you 10 mph leeway - meaning on that ro…

That's ridiculous. A 35mph collision with a pedestrian would almost certainly result in a dead pedestrian. 25mph is usually survivable.[1] A 20mph speed limit, strictly enforced would drop pedestrian fatality rates to essentially 0.[2] 1: http://humantransport.org/sidewalks/SpeedKills.htm 2: http://www.visionzeroinitiative.com/

The lowest limit in my state (aside from 15 in some parking lots) is 25. It is rare for anyone to go below 30, most are going about 35.

Re: Citizen uses OpenCV to track speeders near his home

#40

This is gross, and reminds me of the nosy old ladies that 'patrol' the neighbourhood around here, only this guy knows C.

Really? Speed is a major factor in pedestrian deaths. In fact, this fellow is responding to a child being hit on his street. Seems like he's identified a problem and is doing something to highlight that problem. Good on him, I say!
Post reply on HN