Live data from Hacker News

Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

reuters.com

291–300 of 561 posts

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#291
post #258

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can add any detail to "sell you out"? Was it explicit violation of expected privacy of the conversation?

Active conspiracy with opposing counsel to drag it out, avoid obvious resolutions, etc. Extremely common with divorce attorneys - and labor law.

That sounds actionable if your lawyer (that you're paying) isn't actually working for you.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#292
post #42

This is going to be a huge chilling factor for employees. You’d no longer be able to disent, or discuss anything non-work related with even the slightest expectation of privacy. Yes they could have accessed logs before but there’s a difference between directed checking after incidents and active surveillance at scale.

Yeah, if at any time Mark can ask Meta AI ‘which of my employees insulted me today’ for example, that’s wild

He's already got the willing-intern-finder.md skill locked and loaded

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#293

I really don't understand how this is legal. I guess Facebook maybe doesn't actually have any compliance requirements in the USA, but time series screenshots of any SRE's screen are going to contain data that should not be stored by some data vacuum. I know Meta has a reputation for shitty data handling practices and US regulations are light compared to Europe, but how are they planning on securing passwords, encrypt…

This data is going to get leaked in a breach. It will be used against you in a court of law. It will be used for training and (regardless of what anyone says) will be used to fire you once the AI can do your job.

And when all of the above happens Meta will be absolved of any responsibility.

I don't understand how it's legal either. I guess we need laws against it yesterday.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#294

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have proof or at least some evidence?

.... I'm not the person you're asking but I can give curious anecdata on a home purchase.... When I bought my home, I had a purchase agreement that said 'I will pay up to 1500$ cash if the property assesses for less than X' (X being the amount I told the realtor I was willing to pay.) And the property happened to assess EXACTLY for X. Collusion in markets is nothing new, and even when we regulate people find ways aro…

Hmmm. Property purchase agreements are rather different in your neck of the woods than mine!

Here (UK) we do have a bit of variety, thanks to devolution and bloody mindedness. I'm talking about English here (possibly Welsh too), rather than British (England + Wales + Scotland) or even UK (England + Wales + Northern Ireland). Wales is actually a bit more complicated than that but let's keep it simple.

Here (England), you advertise a house price and invite buyers. You generally engage one or more estate agents (realtors) I think it is called an "invitation to treat" in legal terms.

... negotiations ...

Once a price is "agreed", contracts are drawn up by both sides and "exchanged". When the exchanged contracts are both accepted, then the contract is binding on both sides. Basically: the Buyer will Buy and the Seller will Sell etc.

I think the US is fairly similar in that you do have to agree to something before it becomes a binding agreement.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#295

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are they merging with Palantir any time soon?

I'd argue Meta is much worse: Palantir builds these systems for the US government which is (hopefully) something you can hold accountable / can reasonably trust. Meta builds these systems for itself to make digital cocaine and sell personal data to profit off everyone (including and moreso primarily the elderly and children). You can't hold them accountable, actually pretty much nobody can hold Zuckerberg accountable…

Does Palantir collect data or just analyze aggregated purchased data? I'm not familiar with the data collecting SDKs available as I don't whore out myself/my sites like that, so maybe there is a pipe directly from them????

Either way, I'd definitely hold those directly responsible for collecting and selling of the data way worse than those that just make use of a product. It's like the war on drugs where those making say they will make as long as there are people wanting to buy

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#296

Yeah, this is crazy, remember when engineers were actually engineers and that meant something? Imagine asking to install spyware on your lawyers' firms' company laptops because you didn't trust them not to make some deal with the judge. Or demanding 24 hour monitoring on everything a doctor does because you need to review the footage at any time. EDIT: While we are here, let's do this for politicians as well :), publ…

> let's do this for politicians as well :), publicly available, auditable 24-hour surveillance

Politicians will be the first to carve out exceptions for themselves for reasons of "security" while everyone else is surveilled.

Yes, it should literally be the opposite -- with power should come accountability. But that's not how these things work in practice.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#298
post #289

Now this is some hacker news. We’ve been moving towards a more and more tyrannical company controlled society for a long time and now they’re straight up doing hacking tactics to train machines to take our jobs. Doesn’t get much more bleak than that.

It really does make one wonder... If you came to work tomorrow and I said you need to donate blood to keep working here, would you?

In this economy?

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Im pretty surprised you're getting so much flak for this. This is the least controversial opinion I've seen on HN. I've been working for ~30 years, and every job I've had, if you actually looked at the IT policies, they were all very clear that work devices were for work, personal devices were for personal stuff. It wouldn't even occur to me to cross the streams. Carrying a second phone for personal stuff is a trivia…

> every job I've had, if you actually looked at the IT policies, they were all very clear that work devices were for work, personal devices were for personal stuff

There's quite a difference between that and zero privacy, and there's also quite a difference between "IT policy says" or "the law permits" and "this is how things ought to be".

That said, between necessary endpoint security and the potential to get caught up in corporate legal disputes I feel like maintaining a strict separation is advisable. But that doesn't mean I support unnecessarily invasive surveillance or think it's a good thing.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#300

I really don't understand how this is legal. I guess Facebook maybe doesn't actually have any compliance requirements in the USA, but time series screenshots of any SRE's screen are going to contain data that should not be stored by some data vacuum. I know Meta has a reputation for shitty data handling practices and US regulations are light compared to Europe, but how are they planning on securing passwords, encrypt…

This is legal for most businesses under US law, especially on company devices. And unfortunately not unheard of. Compliance with this data is typically handled in the same way you'd handle any data access situation -- by restricting access to the screencaps to a specific group of people.

Not that I support it -- but typically companies don't do this in spite of security concerns, they do it to address security concerns. But of course, what meta is doing sounds like a different situation. It sounds like they want to make a model that replaces part of their workforce.

Post reply on HN