Live data from Hacker News

AI Usage Policy

github.com

291–293 of 293 posts

Re: AI Usage Policy

#291
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Problem is people seriously believe that whatever GPT tells them must be true, because… I don't even know. Just because it sounds self-confident and authoritative? Because computers are supposed to not make mistakes? Because talking computers in science fiction do not make mistakes like that? The fact that LLMs ended up having this particular failure mode, out of all possible failure modes, is incredibly unfortunate…

I don't remember exactly who said it, but at one point I read a good take - people trust these chatbots because there's big companies and billions behind them, surely big companies test and verify their stuff thoroughly? But (as someone else described), GPTs and other current-day LLMs are probabilistic. But 99% of what they produce seems feasible enough.

> But 99% of what they produce seems feasible enough.

This being a big part of the problem-- their false answers are more plausible and convincing then the truth. The output almost always seems feasible-- true or not is an entirely different matter.

Historically when most things fail they produce nonsense. If they do they are producing something related to the truth (but perhaps biased or mis-calibrated). LLM output can be both highly plausible and unrelated to reality.

Re: AI Usage Policy

#292
I wholeheartedly agree. It's the people that are the problem, not the technology. In the hands of people who understand it's utility and limitations, AI becomes an assistant you can't imagine life without. In the hands of people who aren't so intellectually curious, it helps them run into a brick wall much faster.

My former boss often shared the words of his father: "A fool with a tool...is still a fool!"

Even more true with AI.

Re: AI Usage Policy

#293
post #196

> No AI-generated media is allowed (art, images, videos, audio, etc.). Text and code are the only acceptable AI-generated content, per the other rules in this policy What's the reason for this? Media is the most likely thing I'd consider using AI for as part of a contribution to an open source project. My code would be hand crafted by me. Any AI use would be similar to Google use: a way to search for examples and exp…

AI generated media is a copyright gray zone.

Very very few companies today have zero lines of AI generated code in their codebases. You can't copyright or patent specific code structures or ways of solving common problems.

Post reply on HN