Live data from Hacker News

Zed is our office

zed.dev

291–300 of 343 posts

Re: Zed is our office

#291
post #197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On MacOS 10.15, I have 2 monitors plus the built in on a macbook pro, and I have Zed windows on all 3 of them all the time.

You have to open three Zed instances, don't you?

No, this works fine with a single Zed instance.

Re: Zed is our office

#292
post #183

Earlier quoted context omitted.

…you’re free to use other editors? People like Zed. They like IntelliJ. They like VSCode. If you have an aesthetic preference against all professionally maintained IDEs, I think you’re in the minority.

...doesn't mean the majority is right :)

It's a personal tool. You're not wrong. Anybody isn't wrong either.

Re: Zed is our office

#293
post #226

I really really don't want comms or multiplayer tools in my IDE. Don't bring the attention economy to my cave of solitude, it's where I go to escape all that noise

This is a strong divider between types of minds. I respect your type, but know that others exist and they want these things. It's not crazy, it's just another way.

[deleted]

Re: Zed is our office

#294
post #226

I really really don't want comms or multiplayer tools in my IDE. Don't bring the attention economy to my cave of solitude, it's where I go to escape all that noise

This is a strong divider between types of minds. I respect your type, but know that others exist and they want these things. It's not crazy, it's just another way.

Yup, shouldn't force specific tools upon developers. Problem is that the comms products don't interop. Still beat to have just one for the entire org or likely have siloed conversations

Re: Zed is our office

#295

Maybe I'm old, jaded, stubborn and paranoid, but something about a coding editor that is controlled by a company is off-putting to me. It's even more off-putting when you add Zoom, Slack and everything else into said editor.

AFAIK it’s all open source. If they go off the rails we could fork it.

while technically possible with massive projects like these its not as simple to simply fork it, because of the man hours involved . its better to keep in the product stands enshitification while one uses it or just use something else.

Re: Zed is our office

#296
post #183

Maybe I'm old, jaded, stubborn and paranoid, but something about a coding editor that is controlled by a company is off-putting to me. It's even more off-putting when you add Zoom, Slack and everything else into said editor.

…you’re free to use other editors? People like Zed. They like IntelliJ. They like VSCode. If you have an aesthetic preference against all professionally maintained IDEs, I think you’re in the minority.

The issue is with social features you might be forced to use it, like Slack instead of Email. I've already had cases where I've been forced to use VSCode to collaborate at work.

I personally worry it's not interoperable enough.

Re: Zed is our office

#297
post #225

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Need to work inside a container because it's 2025 and we don't need to clutter our local machine with 100s of dependencies and env managers... “Can I tell you about our lord and saviour Nix?” Kidding, but seriously though I’ve found having to work in a container to be a bit clumsy, even with good tooling around it. As you said it’s 2025, and there are other ways to have reproducible toolchains that don’t pollute th…

> “Can I tell you about our lord and saviour Nix?” The "just use Nix" people are just like the "write it in Rust" brigade. And the things both groups promote share exactly the same problem ... A stupidly enormous learning curve. That's why your average person prefers to just the job done in a container vs Nix, or in Go vs Rust. I'm sure Nix is awesome, just like I'm sure Rust is awesome. But honestly, I've got enough…

So you rather stay comfortable doing what you were always doing, which is fine but programming is everything but that...

Re: Zed is our office

#298
post #225

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Need to work inside a container because it's 2025 and we don't need to clutter our local machine with 100s of dependencies and env managers... “Can I tell you about our lord and saviour Nix?” Kidding, but seriously though I’ve found having to work in a container to be a bit clumsy, even with good tooling around it. As you said it’s 2025, and there are other ways to have reproducible toolchains that don’t pollute th…

> “Can I tell you about our lord and saviour Nix?” The "just use Nix" people are just like the "write it in Rust" brigade. And the things both groups promote share exactly the same problem ... A stupidly enormous learning curve. That's why your average person prefers to just the job done in a container vs Nix, or in Go vs Rust. I'm sure Nix is awesome, just like I'm sure Rust is awesome. But honestly, I've got enough…

Rust forces you to consider things upfront, or to put it another way, a C developer does what the borrow checker does manually. Sometimes, they do it after asan/ubsan/tsan has reported the issue. Sometimes it's after a segfault. Usually it's after the user hits the bug already.

Nix similarly forced issues to be reasoned with upfront.

Re: Zed is our office

#299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> “Can I tell you about our lord and saviour Nix?” The "just use Nix" people are just like the "write it in Rust" brigade. And the things both groups promote share exactly the same problem ... A stupidly enormous learning curve. That's why your average person prefers to just the job done in a container vs Nix, or in Go vs Rust. I'm sure Nix is awesome, just like I'm sure Rust is awesome. But honestly, I've got enough…

So you rather stay comfortable doing what you were always doing, which is fine but programming is everything but that...

Complexity for the sake of complexity is not a goal everyone should be striving for.

Re: Zed is our office

#300

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With the AI stuff, it feels like they invested a bit prematurely. When the Agentic editing demo came out (6 months, 10 months ago? It’s a blur), it felt right. Accepting and reviewing edits, live tracking ..etc., felt like pair programming. The ACP addition felt like a natural evolution . With the continuous improvement in CLI tools and people’s experience with them, it feels like doing a live review or edit-by-edit…

I used to only use JetBrains for AI stuff, now I just open everything in Zed because of its Claude Code integration. Especially with the linters and other nice to haves. I am insanely close to cancelling JetBrains.

Theres a plugin for Claude Code and you can use Claude models from Copilot in IntelliJ. Are those options worse than Zed, especially considering other comments about Zed missing basic editor stuff?
Post reply on HN