Live data from Hacker News

Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

fortune.com

291–300 of 481 posts

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#291

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would you not go first? If you are blind it cannot be worse (well it can, but there are always risks). My wife went through semi-expetimental therapy (at that time) for her MS. It was tough but ultimately a net benefit. It all depends on what is at stake - I would consider Ozempic for some weight loss but prefer, for now , go for no sugar and moderate portions. This is not life changing for me so I indeed prefer…

I guess I don't have a similar thought process as someone who thinks going no sugar is the right way to achieve weight loss. The reason you might think twice about going first is for that exact reason, there are risks. Plenty of blind people would prefer to stay as they are than be left worse off to a greater degree after undergoing the implant.

How would you go for weight loss then? This is calories in - calories out.

And as for which state one wants to be in, this is a matter of personal choice. I know that I will commit suicide right after I get a diagnosis of, say, Alzheimer's (after cleaning up my stuff). If I went blind and had a reasonable chance to get back to sight, then I would also go for it, weighing the risks.

It all boils down to what someone perceives as "better"

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#293

Friends with Parkinson's with neural implants anecdotally report great results, but of course with rather coarse tech. There seems to be lots of future potential. https://www.parkinson.org/living-with-parkinsons/treatment/s...

Has this been used for other health issues too?

Yes, it comes from pacemaker tech, and is used for all kinds of dbs applications like this and also for pain blocking applications

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#294

I think anyone who chooses to undergo the first few trials of a new operation like this, and is informed about the risks, is very brave. I do not know much of anything about medical science, but my impression is that we are still very, very far from having a deep grasp of how both the brain and the immune system work. Ultimately, to the body an implant is simply a foreign object. Many tech professionals work on proje…

> I think anyone who chooses to undergo the first few trials of a new operation like this, and is informed about the risks, is very brave.

Brave and/or incredibly desperate.

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#295
post #289

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Nothing he does is to benefit other people The only way Elon makes money is through people voluntarily giving it to him in exchange for what he creates.

That, and billions of government contracts and subsidies.

The government contracts were simply being paid for a service, like you paying a taxi for a ride. Not a gift in any way, shape, or form.

The subsidies were EV subsidies, which were available for all electric cars.

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#296

Everyone who has ever worked in security: “Ain’t no way”.

Yeah, there is a whole interesting story about the Thoratec Heartmate II bloodbpump ("artificial heart") implant and Dick Chaney. Can't be having a back door into the VPs heart implant...

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#297
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would you not go first? If you are blind it cannot be worse (well it can, but there are always risks). My wife went through semi-expetimental therapy (at that time) for her MS. It was tough but ultimately a net benefit. It all depends on what is at stake - I would consider Ozempic for some weight loss but prefer, for now , go for no sugar and moderate portions. This is not life changing for me so I indeed prefer…

It's a brain chip. How do you feel about being blind and paralyzed? Or comatose? Or dead? How about never-ending pain or constant bright flashes? What if they go bankrupt, and something happens to the implant? Brain surgery isn't exactly an industry where "move fast and break things" is an acceptable approach - especially when you are the patient. Considering Neuralink's historical record, going first sounds like a h…

How do you feel about not having THE sense that defines your whole life? This is a matter of personal choice and weighing risks vs your life as it is.

Nobody is forcing anybody to have the chip - my question was about the reasons behind not taking it for someone who is blind, as a matter of curiosity. It is obvious that everyone will react differently.

As I mentioned, my wife went for that and it was quite a ride initially. You do not want to be on the witnessing side of such treatments but I respect her choice despite the risks.

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would you not go first? If you are blind it cannot be worse (well it can, but there are always risks). My wife went through semi-expetimental therapy (at that time) for her MS. It was tough but ultimately a net benefit. It all depends on what is at stake - I would consider Ozempic for some weight loss but prefer, for now , go for no sugar and moderate portions. This is not life changing for me so I indeed prefer…

what therapy did your wife go through?

The very early form of TYSABRI

Re: Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed

#300
post #284

I'm sure that lives of those animals whom are being tortured for this tech to be developed were changed as well.

As you typed these words, millions of animals out in the wild were being devoured alive by other animals. Torture was here before humans.
Post reply on HN