Live data from Hacker News

Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

thecity.nyc

291–300 of 350 posts

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#291
post #225

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are only fine if everyone is fine. If it can happen to a brown person, it can happen to you - maybe have a little self interest, or perhaps consider how boring America would be without immigrants and black people - that's kinda where all our culture comes from, in our melting pot everything blends together.

Nice try. I'm an immigrant and a minority myself, not that people like you ever actually care about supporting people like me.

Great, so am I (different country though).

So, what are your thoughts about ICE going after immigrants who think they're legal but didn't dot all the i's and cross all the t's on their paperwork? Because that is in the news as well.

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#292
post #201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And yet they hold every single branch of government.

The chance to fix that is in 2026 at the ballot, and preparation every day until then. The whole "there won't be elections" hysteria is exactly because the current MAGA movement is scared shitless of being rejected again. Furthermore, if Trump-y candidates do poorly in 2026, he'll be a lame duck president with little political clout for his final 2 years. Politicians are many things, but charitable to unpopular peopl…

Trump promised his followers won't have to vote any more. Why would he promise that if there will be fair elections in 2026 and 2028?

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#293
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Call your elected representatives I have never seen this work for something this politicized.

Elected representatives are going to be intransigent until a point in the very near future, when they realize they're about to be voted out en masse and their voters don't like them as much as they like another guy -- who isn't going to be on the ballot with them. So keep reminding them.

That happened - it was 2024. It's really seeming like Democrat politicians don't actually care about winning elections. They did terribly and they're still doing terribly and not acknowledging they're doing terribly, when they should have the easiest job in the world running against Trump.

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#295
post #254
post #253

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think the “national electorate” should have any say in California state laws? Is it just a basic lack of understanding civics, or do you think states, cities and local communities should be abolished because people in Alabama should actually be in charge of people in Sacramento? I’m so tired of absolute nonsense like this being said by people who clearly know absolutely nothing about how this country works…

> Why do you think the “national electorate” should have any say in California state laws? Is it just a basic lack of understanding civics, or do you think states, cities and local communities should be abolished because people in Alabama should actually be in charge of people in Sacramento? Immigration law isn't California state law, it's federal law, duly passed (and frankly any other approach would be crazy, unles…

The legislature writes unconstitutional laws all the time.

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#296
post #201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The chance to fix that is in 2026 at the ballot, and preparation every day until then. The whole "there won't be elections" hysteria is exactly because the current MAGA movement is scared shitless of being rejected again. Furthermore, if Trump-y candidates do poorly in 2026, he'll be a lame duck president with little political clout for his final 2 years. Politicians are many things, but charitable to unpopular peopl…

Well said - this is exactly what we have to do. The Blue Wave is coming - every state.

[dead]

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#297
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Police in general don’t need to show warrants to arrest people. In high profile situations it may be done to minimize political blowback, but clearly that is not a primary concern in this situation (except toward individual officers, which is why they are masking). In many situations, they just need a documentable/articulable (to a judge, later) reasonable belief that a crime was occurring in their presence, or in ot…

That all makes sense, but these don't look like police officers — these are guys wearing backwards baseball caps and surgical masks. Effectively, our trust that someone holds position of authority in law enforcement is based on their uniform and badge. If we normalize some dude in a mask and a baseball cap as someone that has the authority to arrest you and put you in an unmarked van, that represents a real and serio…

Yup, and don’t forget DEA getting into full on shoot outs while dressed even worse.

It’s a real problem, just like no knock warrants, asset seizure, lack of body cams, milsurplus equipment grants to police departments, overly aggressive training, parallel construction, arrest quotas, etc.

IMO, in this case the tactics are being done intentionally (and at the leadership level) to terrorize people and stir the pot to incite ‘bad behavior’ that can be spun to justify crackdowns. Individual officers may be true believers, but many are also ‘along for the ride’ and trying to not get too much blowback. Either way, just following orders is no excuse.

Troll in Chief.

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#298
post #257

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So I ask this question in good faith: What are the due process rights that have been taken away? What is this administration doing different from the prior ones in regards to detaining suspected illegal immigrants? While I don't doubt there could be something, I haven't seen a coherent answer to this question. I am happy to change my mind, but in this situation all I see is a political candidate interfering with fede…

They're deporting them without trial. They don't even try to confirm they capture the right people. They've arrested several US citizens. Notice where this arrest occurred: at a courthouse. Why? Because this person was complying with the law and going through the immigration process. What about masked men kidnapping random people, then sending them somewhere like a prison in El Salvador seems just to you? Do you reme…

My understanding is that they're doing this under the "expedited removal" provision of the 1996 IIRIRA law. If you've been in the US less than 2 years, arrived without inspection or at a port of entry with invalid documents, or don't have lawful resident status, you're subject to expedited removal. If not, you are entitled to an administrative immigration hearing.

For some context, under Obama in 2013, there were roughly 197,000 expedited removals (45% of ~432,000 total deportations). So this was widely used by DHS during the Obama administration. Nothing has changed except ICE policies about where people are permitted to be detained and where they are targeting people. Unless I'm missing something?

I'll be the first to admit they look like masked goons and entirely unprofessional grabbing people off the street in hoodies. It's horrible optics and is absurdly unprofessional. I completely disagree with the mechanics of how this is being carried out. But it's not unconstitutional or unlawful as far I can tell.

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#299

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I hope you eventually look back on this part of your life with shame about your beliefs and who and what you defended. I suspect his post will read as a calm and level-headed analysis 10-20 years from now. He showed no support or protest against any political policy.

banal, even.

"banal" --- what a word to use !

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eichmann_in_Jerusalem

Re: Brad Lander detained by masked federal agents inside immigration court

#300
post #262
post #261

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where in the black letter law does it say that ICE are allowed to arrest US nationals?

What does that have to do with anything? If you believed some ICE officers were making illegal arrests (presumably you know their arrests are perfectly legal, since I can't see why else you'd bring up "black letter law"), the remedy for that would be to bring charges for wrongful imprisonment, not to take it as an excuse to obstruct or attack other ICE officers.

>What does that have to do with anything?

You do realize that this entire discussion is about an American citizen and an elected official no less (and not the first one) arrested by "ICE" (we don't really know who those folks are because they won't identify themselves), right?

Are you that removed from reality that you can't parse the title of the discussion in which you are participating?

Post reply on HN