Live data from Hacker News

RIAA’s YouTube-dl takedown ticks off developers and GitHub’s CEO

torrentfreak.com

291–292 of 292 posts

Re: RIAA’s YouTube-dl takedown ticks off developers and GitHub’s CEO

#291

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cartels often mint money.

Of course, for their owners. It OBVIOUSLY reasonable to have three private corporations owning the majority of modern musical output... and they even have a little club where they discuss pricing! How quaint... The outrageous thing is why the fuck we as a society defend these corporations, when they have a literal monopoly on what they’re selling, and the monopoly is guaranteed by the government of every western coun…

Durable cartels are effective and useful --- generally to at least their members and some class of politicians. Copyright / media cartels have long been closely affiliated with politics and politicians, of all stripes, and in the US of both parties.

Media offers money, exposure, glamour and/or star power, spectacle, distraction, attention, and manipulation, all of interest to politicians.

Much of recent copyright law, and the DMCA specifically, was largely driven by Democrats.

Re: RIAA’s YouTube-dl takedown ticks off developers and GitHub’s CEO

#292
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not GP, but I understand what they are getting at. They were shortening to be concise. What was actually meant was... "You will not be able to use it for anything because YouTube and every other video sharing website supported by youtube-dl will have changed a million times.

... which revision is equally based upon the erroneous premise that all of those WWW sites are the same as YouTube. Clearly, with all of the hundreds of "extractors", they are not.

No, they aren't the same. But they will all change regularly and invalidate their corresponding extractor just as quickly.
Post reply on HN