Live data from Hacker News

You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

techcrunch.com

291–300 of 329 posts

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#291

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, FOSS saving a close source platform, what's news? You are completely missing the point, my point was that Apple is so bad of a company that they completely refuse to ship with GPLv3 software, they are nothing but a bunch of immoral fascists. Take take take, but never give anything back. The GNU project did everything right by moving to GPLv3. And last time I checked, brew doesn't work so well when you have multi…

> they are nothing but a bunch of immoral fascists. Yep. The Apple death count must be nearing that of WWII by now surely.

If you cannot see anything immoral in Apple, or if you're unable to see anything immoral/fascist beyond murder and WWII then I'm not sure you're ready to discuss this subject.

I suggest you educate yourself on the matter, because judging by your comment, I can clearly see you're ignorant about the subject.

https://www.gnu.org/proprietary/malware-apple.html

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#292

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any links for more info about containers vs VM there? The article just says: "That’s because Google is going to start shipping Chrome OS with a custom virtual machine that runs Debian Stretch, the current stable version of the operating system."

I have been using this on my pixelbook and, unless I am wildly mistaken, it's generating an LXC container. Android apps for instance all run inside a single container for them as well The container itself is running Debian Stretch. However, for someone not using this it can be easily misinterpreted to mean a VM. Functionally it's not much different.

No it is a container on top of a VM. Different kernels. Android is just a container sharing a common Linux container with ChromeOS.

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#293
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

apt-get is still the golden standard for installing apps on Linux because of its dependency resolution system, and being able to "sudo apt-get install " is a core use-case for end-users (i.e. students who are learning how to use Linux / code for the first time). Disclaimer: I work at Google, but not on Chrome OS.

Genuinely asking, what makes apt-get that much better than other package managers? Outside of Slackware I think good dependency resolution is pretty much universal at this point, and I can't say I've ever noticed any major problems with pacman, for instance.

It is better because it is more common

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#294

Neat! So now you can run JavaScript "IDE" inside a browser inside a Linux VM inside a browser on Linux!

is chrome OS still considered a browser if it's providing a VM for non-javascript applications?

Chrome is a browser.

Chrome OS is, as the name suggests, an OS.

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#295

Will this make it possible to run Docker in a Chromebook? With Crouton, which is just a chroot, you can't run Docker at all (without changing the ChromeOS kernel), and can only run rkt containers. If this new Linux apps support really runs in a Debian KVM virtual machine, then maybe it will be possible to run Docker in that, which would be a massive advantage over what crouton provides. Anybody know?

You could already use Docker containers with Crouton. Just had to use rkt.

Yes docker is working with this new funtionality. You use on a machine container. Which runs on a VM.

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#296
post #235

Will this make it possible to run Docker in a Chromebook? With Crouton, which is just a chroot, you can't run Docker at all (without changing the ChromeOS kernel), and can only run rkt containers. If this new Linux apps support really runs in a Debian KVM virtual machine, then maybe it will be possible to run Docker in that, which would be a massive advantage over what crouton provides. Anybody know?

I've been running Docker on my Chromebook for years. I just installed GalliumOS on it (a native Linux OS tuned for Chromebooks). It works really well.

Better approach, I'm, is use Crouton. Just have to use rkt to launch the containers. Now not necessary to even use developer.

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#297
post #71
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

MacBooks are out for me now that they have the touchbar and bad keyboard. I currently use a ThinkPad and it's pretty good, but the touchpad is mediocre at best. I think a ChromeBook with really first class support for Linux apps is very compelling. I run Linux in a VM on Windows 10 on my ThinkPad and it's a great setup. A ChromeBook would be a very similar setup but probably with better native OS integration (for exa…

You mean pixelbook, $300 chromebooks would obviously be of poor build quality; although i am not sure of the hardware quality of pixelbook either. For me a thinkpad works pretty well for a linux machine.

There are excellent CBs below $300. I have purchased several refurb Acer 14s for $200.

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#298
post #2

Are there any good reasons why a developer would buy a Chromebook over some other laptop, unless they are developing for the Chromebook itself?

You can install GalliumOS [1] on a Chromebook for a full Debian-based Linux experience. I dual boot mine for certain apps I can't run under ChromeOS, but I'll be perfectly happy to stay in Chrome land once this Linux app thing gets pushed out to my chrmebook. For the most part, I'm doing heavy lifting on other machines I remote log into (graphical or shell). I've got LXC and KVM scripts [2] to spin up virtual Windows…

No need now with support built in and have much better security versus using GalliumOS.

Re: You can now run Linux apps on Chrome OS

#300
post #29

I guess "web apps" are not as successful as Google hoped. There are some great web apps, but they are electron apps ... Maybe bake in "elevated" mode in Chrome so it basically becomes Electron, but with some kernel hooks to limit an apps abilities and let users pick what the app is able to access, network, hdd, etc.

Google has 60% of K12 in the US coming decades later than Apple and MS and a fail?
Post reply on HN